Kindness, Pursuit, And Fearful Mercy (Jude 1:22-23)

“22 Keep being kind to those who waver in this faith and convince those who doubt. 23 Pursue those who are singed by the flames of God’s wrath, and bring them safely to Him, snatching them out of the fire. Show mercy to others with fear, despising every garment soiled by the corruption of human flesh.”[1]

 Jude highlights three different types of people within the church who have been influenced by the words and lifestyle of false teachers.[2]

·      Those who doubt. “I think or feel this wavering way.” Be kind, and offer convincing truth to stabilize their faith.

·      Those whose doubt leads to wrong action. “I think I will walk down a wavering road because of it.” Pursue them and grab them out of the judgment that follows their actions.

·      Those who try to take other down with them. “In fact, I want you to join me.” Show mercy, but with great caution, and with no mistaking the sinful pollution their lives carry with them.

I want to try some analogies about how these three situations are different, and why our responses are different. 

SCENARIO #1: Hot Headed Basketball Player

·      I can see frustration building, so I get his attention and gesture, “calm down.” It’s an inner battle. I’m gentle….

·      He’s about to go OFF and get a technical. I yank him off the floor immediately and get in his face. This inner battle is going to get him in trouble because he’s going to act on it in the wrong way. I snatch him from the referee fire. 

·      He’s muttering, swearing, making the whole bench agitated. Now he is polluting the team. It’s time to head to the locker room. You need some social distancing or quarantine, because you are infectious.

SCENARIO #2: My College Roommate

·      “Should I go to a packed, closed room for a concert where we all sing along at the top of our lungs in a COVID hotspot for 3 hours?” He’s having an inner battle. You gently talk about how it is a bad idea, because it’s a bad idea. 

·      “I have called an Uber to take me to the concert.”  This inner battle is going to get him in trouble because he’s going to act on it in the wrong way. You snatch him from the medical fire and cancel that Uber. 

·      *spends 3 hours at the packed concert full of people who were coughing and sneezing and singing at the top of their lungs.*  Now he is polluting the dorm. I pray for his health and decision making and maybe even help him pay for his doctor visit, but he can’t live in this dorm without a quarantine. 

SCENARIO #3: A Brother/Sister In Christ

·      “I’m struggling with how to balance freedom in Christ and responsibility in Christ.” Inner battle. Gentle. Let’s talk and pray and study Scripture together.

·      “I’m thinking I will go to Vegas for a week and just experience everything I can.” The inner battle is about to lead into sinful actions. It’s time to be more forceful and intervene. 

·      “I got a bunch of guys from church to go with me…” Let me stop you right there. Now you are polluting the body. I love you, but you are infectious right now.  Your presence is spiritually toxic because you are dragging those around you into your sin. [3]

So, let’s explore each of these a bit more. I’m not going to tell you how to apply the different approaches. You are going to need the Holy Spirit and probably the advice of other Christians to know how to enter into a particular situation where someone is struggling in their Christian faith. There is not a ‘one size fits all’ approach. May God give us wisdom. 

THOSE WHO ARE WAVERING

Show mercy and patience. It would be easy to get frustrated, or just throw arguments at them. But Jude leads with something relational: mercy and kindness. Offer convincing reasons that point them toward the truth, but with mercy and kindness. You are on the same team. This is a bruised reed that we don't want to break (Isaiah 42:3).  We have received God’s unmerited mercy; we should pass this on to those who are wavering.  I like how William Barclay summarizes what he sees as our duty as a fellow Christian in this situation:  

 “Study to be able to defend the faith and to give a reason for the hope that is in us. We must know what we believe so that we can meet error with truth; and we must make ourselves able to defend the faith in such a way that our graciousness and sincerity may win others to it.”

THOSE WHO ARE SINGED BY THE FIRE.  

 Almost everyone agrees that this is imagery from Zechariah 3:1-4:

Then he showed me Joshua the high priest standing before the angel of the Lord, and Satan standing at his right side to accuse him. The Lord said to Satan, “The Lord rebuke you, Satan! The Lord, who has chosen Jerusalem, rebuke you! Is not this man a burning stick snatched from the fire?” Now Joshua was dressed in filthy clothes as he stood before the angel. The angel said to those who were standing before him, “Take off his filthy clothes. ” Then he said to Joshua, “See, I have taken away your sin, and I will put rich garments on you. ”

 Remember the filthy clothes for the third category.  As for the fire imagery, when Amos (speaking for God) unfolds a laundry list of sinfulness, he notes:

“I overthrew some of you as I overthrew Sodom and Gomorrah. You were like a burning stick snatched from the fire, yet you have not returned to me,” declares the Lord.”

 So this is the imagery. There are people in the church so corrupted by the false teachers they have gone beyond just wavering and are now actively living in a way that is deserving of the just judgment of God being poured out in them either now[4] or in eternity. God’s people are not to push them away; they are to pursue them and actually act as God’s instrument in pulling them away from the direction of the fire. William Barclay once again: 

“There are those who have to be snatched from the fire. They have actually started out on the wrong way and have to be stopped, as it were, forcibly, and even against their will. It is all very well to say that we must leave a man his freedom and that he has a right to do what he likes. All these things are in one sense true, but there are times when a man must be even forcibly saved from himself.”

THOSE WHOSE SIN IS SO INFECTIOUS THAT EVEN BEING AROUND THEM POSES A DANGER 

Jude is probably referencing the false teachers and those in the church who have given their allegiance to them.  If you remember from previous sermons, this had resulted in significant immorality. Their false ideas had led to a blatantly sinful lifestyle.[5]

Jude does not mince words about how dangerous they are. The “soiled” garments is Jude’s version of the Hebrew word for “filthy” found in Zechariah 3:3. This word refers to human excrement. And Jude’s word for clothes refers to undergarments. In other words, the sinful practices (“corrupted flesh”) of these people are disgusting, like crap-filled underwear. Jude’s words, not mine. 

So if false teachers are that disgusting, how are they so dangerous? Because we don’t see them as disgusting. Wolves don’t slip into the fold by looking like wolves. Hidden reefs don’t loom above the waves. They are dangerous because they look so amazing even as they begin to kill us. 

Maybe the best modern parable on this is vampires. Stay with me here. The original Dracula book was far more Christian than you realize,[6] and Hollywood took his very unappealing version and made vampires sexy. What makes them so terrible now is that we know they are undead, damned. We know they are monsters. But there is something about them that draws the victim. To Bella in Twilight, they glitter in the sun. There’s a reason the first Twilight book cover features an apple. It’s the oldest temptation: something evil is made to look good. 

Taylor Swift has an interesting song called “Illicit Affairs” on her latest album. In it, she notes how what looks good at the beginning ends badly.   

And that's the thing about illicit affairs and clandestine meetings and stolen stares,They show their truth one single time, but they lie and they lie and they lie
A million little times. 

And you know damn well: for you, I would ruin myself
A million little times.

 This is what sin does. It lies and lies and lies. And it ruins us. In the worst case scenario, this is what false teachers and their followers in the church do: they lie and lie and lie, and ask us to ruin ourselves a million little times. 

So when we are around those whose very presence spreads the infection of sinful ideas and actions we might not know it. We might think it looks and sounds amazing – the monstrous can look bright and dazzling in the right light. We may be deceived. We might not recognize all the lies, and we might be experiencing ruin even while we think we are having fun. 

Most of the pastors and commentators I read believe the “mercy” Jude says we should show is primarily in the form of sincere prayer are not beyond redemption. Our history never has to be our destiny. 

But I suspect this mercy goes beyond that. Mercy is not a vague theory; it’s practically experienced. So we pray for those who are lost in even the deepest depths of sin, but we also find a way to be present with a mercy that is tempered by “fear.”

Think of “fear” as significant caution as we have contact with someone like this. It would be easy to become infected. We pray for them as an act of mercy that reminds us that God is merciful to even the worst of us. We can all do that. But we might need to do some social distancing if our spiritual immune system is low. We might need some church discipline that creates some space between someone who is toxic and those who are susceptible. And we will definitely need to be oh, so careful, as we move closer to help.  

Yet even here God's wondrous grace can exchange the excrement-covered garments (Zec 3:3) for festive garments of righteousness. For no one, not even the most defiled sinner, is beyond salvation through faith in Christ's redeeming work. (Douglas Moo)

 In this is where we land: in the grace of God. 

I love this verse in Jude. Every scenario has hope, from the doubter to the vampire. And it tells us how to point toward that hope.

Be kind. Don’t be a jerk. Don’t call people names or bully them. 

Offer truth. You can do that while being kind. Kindness isn’t wimpy. Kindness is about the attitude; Truth is about pointing toward reality. 

Pursue. We don’t wait for the drowning to swim to us. We swim to them. 

Show mercy (even if it has to be tempered with caution). We can all pray. I suspect that changes our attitude.  We can pursue even if we pull up 6 feet short and with a mask on. We can rescue the drowning even if it’s just by throwing them something to float on so they don’t die while waiting for the lifeguard. 

Kindness. Truth. Pursuit. Mercy. Once again, a compelling vision of life in the Kingdom.  In this kind of community, there is freedom to be honest at the very beginning of wavering so that future hardship can be avoided.

In this kind of community, there is reason to never lose hope even when we are spiritually toxic, because neither God nor his people have given up. 

____________________________________________________________________________

[1] This verse in Jude likely inspired a few lines in an early Christian document called the Didache: “You shall hate no one, but some you must reprove, for some you must pray, and some you must love more than your very life.”

[2] Warren Wiersbe calls these three groups of people The Doubting (Jude 1:22), The Burning (Jude 1:23a), The Dangerous (Jude 1:23b).

[3] There’s an episode in The Walking Dead where a deeply traumatized young girl starts to wonder if the Walkers (zombies) are just normal people. The adults with her try gently to explain to her that’s not true. Soon they find her trying to hang out with them to prove them wrong, and they literally snatch her from the zombie ‘fire’. She’s angry, but at least she’s safe. Then they find out she is planning to kill someone in their group to prove to them that becoming a Walker is no big deal. Now, it’s not just about her. The lives of others are on the line. Note the escalation: it’s a similar pattern to what Jude is describing.

[4] Amos’ Sodom and Gomorrah reference was a ‘real time’ example.

[5] When Paul wrote to the Corinthian church (1 Corinthians 5) about an unrepentant, incestuous church member, he said, “So when you are assembled and I am with you in spirit, and the power of our Lord Jesus is present, hand this man over to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved on the day of the Lord.” I think this is excommunication, and is an act of mercy (see the reason) with ‘fear’.

[6] https://www.premierchristianity.com/Blog/Why-Dracula-is-the-most-Christian-show-on-TV

Keeping Yourselves In The Love Of God (Jude 1:14-19)

Jude’s been warning about false teachers and describing how to recognize them. Here is his summary – and the turn toward a hope-filled ending to a letter that has been pretty sobering so far. 

14 Enoch, the seventh from Adam, prophesied about them: “See, the Lord is coming with thousands upon thousands of his holy ones 15 to judge everyone, and to convict all of them of all the ungodly acts they have committed in their ungodliness, and of all the defiant words ungodly sinners have spoken against him.” 16 These people are grumblers and faultfinders; they follow their own evil desires; they boast about themselves and flatter others with empty words[1] for their own advantage.[2]

 We are getting to a summary: notice Jude’s reference again to both words and acts that characterize false teachers.

17 But, dear friends, remember what the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ foretold. 18 They said to you, “In the last times there will be scoffers who will follow their own ungodly desires.” 19 These are the people who divide you, who follow mere natural instincts and do not have the Spirit.

 So, we have been in the “last times” for 2,000 years, and all this time we have had to resist being divided in the church by those in the church whose words and action do not reflect the indwelling and guidance of the Holy Spirit.  

20 But you, dear friends, by building yourselves up in the object of your most holy faith[3] and praying in the Holy Spirit,21 keep yourselves in God’s love as you wait for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ to bring you to eternal life.

 Here’s the turn: after a letter filled with dire warning about the disease in their midst, Jude offers the cure. 

·      We use different, holy words -  truth that build on the foundation of Jesus.

·      We follow different, holy paths -  righteousness that unite us.

·      We have a different, holy hope – the mercy of Christ stretching into eternity

How to keep yourself in God’s love. 

In this passage, Jude is not telling the believers that they have to keep themselves saved. He begins and ends this letter with a reminder that God is our keeper: 

“Jude, a bond-servant of Jesus the Christ, and brother of James, To those who are the called, beloved in God the Father, and kept for Jesus the Christ.” (Jude 1:1)[4] 

“Now to Him who is able to keep you from stumbling, and to make you stand in the presence of His glory blameless with great joy…” (Jude 1:24)

A translator named Wuest translates verse 21 a follows: "With watchful care keep yourselves within the sphere of God's love." In other words, Jude seems to be saying, "keep yourself in the place where you experience in this life the blessing that God's love brings." I’ve talked before about we invest sweat equity so that we experience the fullness of life in the Kingdom. I think this is the idea here. William MacDonald writes, 

"The love of God can be compared to sunshine. The sun is always shining. But when something comes between us and the sun, we are no longer in the sunshine." [5]

It’s as if we have our own cloud generating machine. Calvin is famous for saying that the human heart is a “perpetual idol factory.” Maybe we leave perpetual chem trails too. The sun won’t stop shining, but we can put something between us and it’s warmth and light. If you have ever flown when it’s cloudy, it’s the difference between life under the cloud cover vs. breaking into the sunlight that was always there. 

So, how do we experience the fullness of blessings in the sphere of the warmth of the love of God? How do we stay in the sunlight of the Son? We walk in obedience to His revealed will. The writers of Scripture tell us this over and over again. 

“For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments; and His commandments are not burdensome.” 1 John 5:3 

"If you love Me, you will keep My commandments.” (John 14:15) 

"He who has My commandments and keeps them is the one who loves Me… and I will love him and will disclose Myself to him." (John 14:21) 

"If you keep My commandments, you will abide in My love; just as I have kept My Father's commandments and abide in His love.” (John 15:10)

 When we remain obedient, we not only demonstrate our love for God, we abide in the love of God. We live in the love of God, and God discloses or reveals himself to us. I don’t think this means the kind of revelation Paul had on the road to Damascus, because Paul was not living in obedience to God. I think it means we begin to understand the heart of God when we order our lives in alignment with the heart of God. 

• My wife and I didn’t understand the joy of tithing until we started to tithe. It was counterintuitive to think that giving  away money that was already tight was going to feel like abundant life, and yet it does. Now we understand more why God loves generosity, and why he wants His children to be generous. 

• “Do not forsake gathering together.” The more I have watched and experienced that in this church both in person and virtually, the more I understand why it’s so important to God for His children to do life together even when it’s really hard. When honesty, transparency, truth, boldness, love, grace, repentance, forgiveness, humility, and service all “click”, it brings tears to my eyes. I remember how Ted would tear up when talk about how much he loved the church. I thought at the time, “I mean, I love the church and all, but you are really emotional.” Now I get it. God is disclosing his heart to me through obedience.  

•  Jesus said the following in Matthew 5: 44-48 -  “Love your enemies. Pray for those who torment you and persecute you— in so doing, you become children of your Father in heaven. He, after all, loves each of us—good and evil, kind and cruel. He causes the sun to rise and shine on evil and good alike. He causes the rain to water the fields of the righteous and the fields of the sinner.  It is easy to love those who love you—even a tax collector can love those who love him. And it is easy to greet your friends—even outsiders do that! But you are called to something higher…” What happens if I do that???? God discloses Himself to me. I begin to understand his heart for the fallen, broken people for whom He gave his life. 

Obedience clears the cloud cover so we live in the full warmth and light of the “sunshine” of His love.

1. Build your foundation in/on the object of your faith. I’m not going to go into detail on this point this morning. We spent 8 weeks last fall going through our statement of faith, which began by focusing on the object of our faith: the triune God –Father, Son and Holy Spirit. I encourage you to revisit that.

 I will note this: Jude is pointing us toward the object of our faith, not our feelings of faith. We often hear conversation about how strong our faith is, or how to build our faith, and it’s often us-centered. By that, I mean it focuses on how we can alter ourselves to have more faith. Jude is pointing us toward the object of our faith. If I am understanding his point correctly, strong faith follows from appreciating the strength of the One in whom we have put our faith.

I was working on a house this week with someone else’s ladder. I’ll be honest - I wasn’t sure about this ladder. It was really light-weight, and well traveled. Plus, when I leaned it against the house, I was on a hill, so one side of the top didn’t even touch the house when I started up. My faith was not strong. The good news – it was fine. However, trying to “drum up” faith in that ladder would have been a little foolish. It just wasn’t the kind of ladder that deserved too much faith. However, I’ve used ladders I could barely move because they were built so solidly. I put them on level ground. My faith was strong. My anxiety was low. It’s a whole different experience.  

This is why, when we struggle of feel spiritually faint, we always look to Jesus. The more we see Him for who He is, the more our faith grows. 

2. Pray with the help of the Holy Spirit. The false teachers “follow mere natural instincts and do not have the Spirit,” which suggests to me a contrast in the next paragraph: Don’t be like that. Pray with and for holy instincts guided by the Holy Spirit. (By the way, this language in Jude is different from other places where the Bible mentions praying in a prayer language. Think of Jude’s discussion here as being about prayer as a fruit of the Spirit rather than a gift of the Spirit. Two different discussions).  

“Only inasmuch as you know that God is your Father can you pray with intimacy rather than with religious ritual. Part of what it means to pray in the Spirit, therefore, is to pray with the help of the Holy Spirit who is constantly reminding you of your position as heir of God. You’re God’s child and, as such, you’re a co-heir with Christ. You can pray with the power of a child of God to a perfect Father.” – Alan Wright 

“To pray in the Spirit, walk in the Spirit, and worship in the Spirit (‘in Spirit and in truth,’ John 4:24) is to come before the Lord according to His appointed means—that is through the One whom the Spirit magnifies, the Lord Jesus Christ (Romans 8:26-27), depending on His revealed Word and pleading as a lesser creature to our glorious Creator.” (Michael Milton, “What Is Praying In The Spirit?” christianity.com) 

“By a principle of grace derived from him, and by his enlightening, quickening, sanctifying, and comforting influences, showing you what blessings you may and ought to pray for, inspiring you with sincere and fervent desires after those blessings, and enabling you to offer these desires to God in faith, with gratitude for the blessings which you have already received.” – Benson Commentary 

“‘Praying in the Holy Ghost’-that is to say, prayer which is not mere utterance of my own petulant desires which a great deal of our ‘ prayer’ is, but which is breathed into us by that Divine Spirit that will brood over our chaos, and bring order out of confusion, and light and beauty out of darkness, and weltering sea.” – MacLaren’s Expositions

It’s prayer…

·      confident in my identity as a child approaching a perfect Father

·      focused on Jesus

·      inspired to pray for what God desires rather than what I want

·      remembering that the one whose Spirit moved over the chaos of Genesis 1 will move over the chaos of this world and bring light, beauty and life.

3. Wait/look for the fulfillment of the mercy of Jesus Christ. This is a future of eternal life, not eternal death.  

·      "And the testimony is this, that God has given us eternal life, and this life is in His Son."– 1 John 5:11

·      " He who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life."– John 5:24

·      “We rest in this hope we’ve been given—the hope that we will live forever with our God—the hope that He proclaimed ages and ages ago (even before time began).” Titus 1:1-2 

Keep yourself in God’s love – clear the cloud cover so that you can live in the unwavering light and warmth of God’s love, mercy and salvation.  

Fix your eyes on Jesus, the author and finisher of our faith. 

Pray in tune with the heart of God, and walk in the path of righteousness revealed in 

Scripture with the help of the inspiration and guidance of God’s Holy Spirit.

Never forget the New Heaven and Earth that awaits those who are covered in His mercy.

THREE QUESTIONS

1. So, God keeps us in His love even as we keep ourselves in God’s love. Hmmm. It seems like we could become overly passive or overly driven if we embrace one side without the other. Talk about living in this tension.

2. The idea that obedience keeps us in the love of God can sound like legalism. How do we offer obedience as an act of loving worship without being caught up in thinking we are earning God’s love or salvation? .

3. In a practical sense, how might “praying in the Spirit” as described here change how you approach prayer? If you are already taking this approach, how have you noticed it reorienting your life or your walk with God?
   _________________________________________________________________________

[1] This parallels a passage in 2 Peter: “For when they speak great swelling words of emptiness, they allure through the lusts of the flesh, through lewdness…” (2:18).” 

[2] Like the false teachers in the Corinthian church who called themselves “super-apostles” and were just ridiculously full of themselves (2 Corinthians 11:5; 12:11; 3:1; 10:13-18; 11:12,18; 4:5; 5:12; 11:20). 

[3] “Both the adjective and the verb show that πίστις is here meant not in a subjective (the demeanour of faith…) but in an objective sense (… “appropriated by them indeed as their personal possession, yet according to its contents…” - Meyer’s New Testament Commentary

[4] " Holy Father, keep them in Your name...” (John 17:11)

[5] Thanks to David Curtis, at bereanbiblechurch.org, for a helpful article.

Hidden Reefs and Love Feasts (Jude 1:12-13; 1 Corinthians 11)

These are hidden reefs in your love feasts, while they feast with you without fear, serving only themselves. They are clouds without water, carried about by the winds; late autumn trees without fruit, twice dead, pulled up by the roots; raging waves of the sea, foaming up their own shame; wandering stars for whom is reserved the blackness of darkness forever.

You live in first century Rome. If you are rich, you know how to feast.[1]

“Popular but costly fare included pheasant, thrush (or other songbirds), raw oysters, lobster, shellfish, venison, wild boar, and peacock…elaborate recipes were invented…with expensive ingredients and elaborate, even dramatic, presentation. For example, in [a fictional story] from 54–68 A.D., one man serves his guests… pig stuffed with sausages, a hare decorated with wings to resemble Pegasus, and various foods arranged in the shape of the twelve signs of the zodiac.”[2]

Tableware was made of “silver, gold, bronze, or semi-precious stones (such as rock crystal, agate, and onyx).”[3] The best cups were engraved with images of Dionysis, god of revelry. One article calls these feasts “A Calculated Display Of Debauchery And Power.”[4] This was a time to wallow in your wealth. This was primarily reserved for men, though really important women could join. If you were poor, this was a world to which you did not have access. It was for the elite. 

“Outside the patrician mansions and saffron-flavored swimming pools, the plebeians lived in overcrowded tenements and ate frugally. Food inequality was as endemic to ancient Rome as it is to our world today, with hunger and hedonism coexisting through the empire… With a population of one million people, the city was hard to feed… We know of 19 food riots in ancient Rome, and there were surely other ones that haven't left a documentary record. During one such riot in the Forum in A.D. 51, caused by a prolonged drought, the Emperor Claudius had to flee for his life.[5]

 The poor appear to have eaten largely a grain or cereal diet, with millet showing up a lot (the rich called this ‘animal food’).[6] 

“The ancient Roman playwright Plautus (c. 254 – 184 B.C.E.) noted a common lament in the ancient world when he wrote that “wretched is the man who has to look for his food himself and has a hard time finding it, but more wretched is one who has a hard time looking for it and does not find anything. And most wretched is that one who does not have anything to eat when he wishes to.’””[7]

 Slaves fared worst of all. They…

“were fed by their masters and sometimes with little more consideration than that afforded to livestock. Some ruthlessly efficient masters even admonished owners to cut food rations for sick slaves and provided instructions on how to feed them according to the amount of work they were expected to do depending on the season, similar to draft animals.”[8]

Enter the church and the subversive presence of the gospel not just in individual lives but in structures and norms. The early church – which was full of slaves, widows and orphans -  began to have their own feasts. They called them “love feasts,” and in Greek, that “love” is a form of the word agape (agapai).

“[it] probably denotes a communal celebration in the church… [it is] the observance of the Lord's Supper (which elsewhere Paul can describe with terms like "coming together to eat,"  1 Cor 11:17-22 ), or… a fellowship meal that may have preceded or followed observance of the Lord's Supper.”[9]

It seems that, perhaps on a weekly basis or even more frequently, the church gathered together to take communion and share a meal, a feast. The wealthy in the church would throw the feast, and everyone, even the poorest of the poor, would get to celebrate. The idea was that the more affluent members of the church would share their abundance of food with the less fortunate. Women, children, and slaves joined in. Entire families feasted together. This was not a “calculated display of debauchery and power,” but of love, service and honor. They didn’t just gather in a common place; they have a common experience. Think of how the church was described in Acts 2:44-46:

“And all who believed were together and had all things in common. And they were selling their possessions and belongings and distributing the proceeds to all, as any had need. And day by day, attending the temple together and breaking bread in their homes, they received their food with glad and generous hearts, praising God and having favor with all the people.”

It’s a great vision for community – “common unity” in Christ, and this sharing of good through both communion and meals or feasts was intended to be a really practical expression of it. We can see that the church had been learning this idea of community throughout the New Testament: In the passages teaching that all women should be veiled and no man should cover their head, it’s a leveling of the playing field by addressing cultural symbols that divided and judged people. This was going to have to be addressed in meals too. 

“Roman communal feasting not only united and classified participants by social rank, it also offered “dramatic confirmation of what we now recognize as a key element for interpreting any eating event—namely, that once we establish the time, place, and participants of any meal, nearly everything else about social relationships in a given society can be brought into sharper focus. Such is the power of food.”[10]

A Roman satirists named Marshall described the hierarchy of food/social status this way: 

“You take oysters fattened in the Lucrine lake; I cut my mouth sucking a mussel from its shell; you get mushrooms, I get swing fungi; you take a turbot (a flatfish delicacy), but I a brill. A golden turtledove with fattened rump fills you up; a magpie dead in its cage is set before me.”[11]

This should never happen in a church love feast. The feast in the church was intended to be a practical demonstration of unity, celebration, and common care that crossed all boundaries. This was meant to be a life-giving “agape”feast both socially and nutritionally, not an unhealthy or sinful indulgence of the appetites of the flesh in which the rich flaunted their luxury and the poor were reminded of theirs.

“In Corinth the agape seems to have been slightly modified by two Grecian customs. One of these customs was the…symposium; a banquet [much like] our modern picnic…the most generous way was for those best able to bring the most liberal amount, and then spread the whole on a common table... The second custom was the Grecian sacrificial feasts, in which an ample supply was furnishe and so moderately eaten that a rich remainder was left for the poor. While Paul remained at Corinth the best qualities of both these pagan customs were exhibited in the love-feasts of the Christians, with some Christian improvements.”[12]

When Paul left Corinth, it seems to have fallen apart. The rich indulged with gluttony and even drunkenness while the poor ate what the poor always ate. This has implications for physical health on both sides for sure, as well as emotional, relation and spiritual health. Paul calls out the Corinthian church in 1 Corinthians 11. 

Context first. In Chapter 9, Paul goes off about how he limits his freedoms and exercises self-discipline:

Though I am free and belong to no one, I have made myself a slave to everyone, to win as many as possible... I have become all things to all people so that by all possible means I might save some.  I do all this for the sake of the gospel, that I may share in its blessings…I strike a blow to my body and make it my slave so that after I have preached to others, I myself will not be disqualified for the prize.”

In Chapter 10 he talks about unity, and surrendering rights to what is beneficial and constructive for the glory of God: 

our ancestors…were all baptized into Moses in the cloud and in the sea… ate the same spiritual food and drank the same spiritual drink…drank from the spiritual rock that accompanied them (Christ)….Is not the cup… and the bread… participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one loaf, we, who are many, are one body, for we all share the one loaf… 

“I have the right to do anything,” you say—but not everything is beneficial. “I have the right to do anything”—but not everything is constructive. No one should seek their own good, but the good of others… So whether you eat or drink or whatever you do, do it all for the glory of God.  Do not cause anyone to stumble, whether Jews, Greeks or the church of God— even as I try to please everyone in every way. For I am not seeking my own good but the good of many, so that they may be saved.

In Chapter 12, spiritual gifts must be surrendered and self-disciplined for the beneficial construction of the body, the church:

Just as a body, though one, has many parts, but all its many parts form one body, so it is with Christ.13 For we were all baptized by[ one Spirit so as to form one body… and we were all given the one Spirit to drink…. those parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable, and the parts that we think are less honorable we treat with special honor…. God has put the body together, giving greater honor to the parts that lacked it,  so that there should be no division in the body, but that its parts should have equal concern for each other. If one part suffers, every part suffers with it; if one part is honored, every part rejoices with it.

Chapter 13, is the Love Chapter, and chapter 14 is all about not just doing things in spiritual practices to edify yourself, but to edify others. 

So, Chapter 11 falls right in the middle of this pattern. Also, remember the food riot that was so bad Claudius had to flee the city? This was written about that same time. 

In the following directives I have no praise for you, for your meetings do more harm than good. In the first place, I hear that when you come together as a church, there are divisions among you, and to some extent I believe it. No doubt there have to be differences among you to show which of you have God’s approval.  

 So then, when you come together, it is not the Lord’s Supper you eat, for when you are eating, some of you go ahead with your own private suppers. As a result, one person remains hungry and another gets drunk. Don’t you have homes to eat and drink in? Or do you despise the church of God by humiliating those who have nothing? What shall I say to you? Shall I praise you? Certainly not in this matter! 

(A meal – the Lord’s supper - meant to unite was highlighting things that divided them: in this case, wealth and food)

For I received from the Lord what I also passed on to you: The Lord Jesus, on the night he was betrayed, took bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke it and said, “This is my body, which is for you; do this in remembrance of me.” In the same way, after supper he took the cup, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood; do this, whenever you drink it, in remembrance of me.” For whenever you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes. 

(The Lord’s supper is about sacrifice and love.) 

So then, whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner[13] (I think in this context[14] it means without a heart to sacrificially share and show love[15]) will be guilty of sinning against the body and blood of the Lord (basically, making a mockery of Christ’s legacy). Everyone ought to examine themselves (their motivation; their hearts; their resources[16]) before they eat of the bread and drink from the cup. For those who eat and drink without discerning the body of Christ (without noticing the needs in the community of the church - they celebrate Christ’s body without seeing Christ’s ‘body’[17]) eat and drink judgment on themselves.[18] That is why many among you are weak and sick, and a number of you have fallen asleep.[19] 

A lot of ink has been spilled trying to figure out what verse 18 means. If  I may offer an ‘at minimum’ reading: “People are sick and dying in your church because you aren’t honoring the sacrificial nature of Christ’s sacrifice, and you have refused to sacrifice yourself for the benefit and construction of the body of Christ.”[20]

 But if we were more discerning with regard to ourselves, we would not come under such judgment. Nevertheless, when we are judged in this way by the Lord, we are being disciplined so that we will not be finally condemned with the world. So then, my brothers and sisters, when you gather to eat, you should all eat together.  (1 Corinthians 11:17-33)

* * * * *

Let’s back up and get the big picture.  

Even good things can become bad if our use or exercise of them shows we don’t ‘discern the body of Christ’ by seeing the people around us and stewarding what God has given us in a way that builds up the ‘body of Christ’ that is assembled in ‘common union.’ 

False teachers are not only wolves, they are lone wolves (even if they run in packs). Their followers are loners as well, seeing themselves as islands, responsible to no one but themselves. It’s as if freedom in Christ was freedom from any obligation outside themselves, when actually Christ frees us to see our obligations in light of the Kingdom and joyfully fulfill them for our good and God’s glory. 

So I’ve been thinking a lot about this for myself. How does ‘discerning the body of Christ’ shape how I view life together in the church?  

• An obvious example is money. And as I’ve been saying, I just love how I have seen so many generous hearts revealed in this congregation in the past few months. That’s “love feast” territory. Sheila and I have been talking more than ever about what it means for us to be more generous in times of concern rather than less generous, because we have this default tendency to want to circle the wagons or claim exclusive ownership of what actually belongs to God. It turns out God has given us family resources to bring to the common table at the family feast. 

• My time. When I have the luxury of lots of time, am I praying about how to “feast with others” in the midst of my plenty? This isn’t to suggest I shouldn’t carve out time for me and God for my health on multiple levels so that I can serve Him well, but am I praying for wisdom about how to share from my abundance with the body of Christ?

•  My talents, gift or skills. If I am good at something, do I only use that to profit myself (which is a necessary things for stewarding a household), or am I also using it for others as I am able? How do those around my benefit from the talents, gifts and skills I bring to the feast? You might think, “All I can do is this.” Unless it’s a sin that you are offering, there are no dishonorable parts. Bring it.

• My words, face to face or in a virtual world. While I am sharing a “love feast”, am I filling the space with truth and grace? Is my verbal fountain yielding fresh and bitter water, or am I drawing from the well that never runs dry? Am I filling the air with gossip, fear and bitterness, or with truth, hope, peace? 

Like Scott pointed out last week, the New Testament writers constantly warn about the creeping danger within the church. The wolves aren’t gate crashers; they have been invited to the feast, and now the church is in danger.
I don’t want to be that person. I want to discern myself and the body of Christ. I want the truth and love of Christ in me to be working in me and embodied through me as I pull up my chair. Because that’s the obvious opposite effect of what Jude and Paul are warning about. In NOT discerning the body of Christ is so bad, just think how good it is when we DO discern the body of Christ? If one path leads to sickness and death, the other path must lead to health and life, right?

Once again, within the warning is the hope. Envision church community characterized by genuine love feasts in the fullest sense of the word: constantly ‘discerning the body of Christ’ by seeing the people around us and stewarding what God has given us in a way that builds up the ‘body of Christ’ that is assembled in ‘common union.’

It’s a glimpse of heaven, an expression of Christ, a vision of Kingdom that points toward the goodness and glory of the God into whose likeness we are constantly being made. 

QUESTIONS

1.    What do you bring to the “love feast”?

2.    How have you experienced the “love feast” gone right or wrong in your church history? What was the result?

3.    How can others in the group pray for you in this area?

 ______________________________________________________________________________

[1] https://eyesofrome.com/blog/eyes-on-storytelling/feasting-roman-style

[2] https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/banq/hd_banq.htm

[3] https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/banq/hd_banq.htm

[4] https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/05/20/712772285/the-lavish-roman-banquet-a-calculated-display-of-debauchery-and-power

[5] https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/05/20/712772285/the-lavish-roman-banquet-a-calculated-display-of-debauchery-and-power

[6] https://www.livescience.com/27569-ancient-romans-ate-millet.html

[7] https://zapruderworld.org/volume-5/food-provisioning-and-social-control-in-ancient-rome/

[8] https://zapruderworld.org/volume-5/food-provisioning-and-social-control-in-ancient-rome/

[9] https://www.biblestudytools.com/dictionaries/bakers-evangelical-dictionary/love-feast.html

[10] https://zapruderworld.org/volume-5/food-provisioning-and-social-control-in-ancient-rome/

[11] https://zapruderworld.org/volume-5/food-provisioning-and-social-control-in-ancient-rome/

[12] https://www.studylight.org/commentaries/whe/1-corinthians-11.html

 [13] “At all events, the unworthiness lies in a lack of living active faith in the atonement which has been achieved by the death of Christ; and this is the source of the various moral disqualifications by which the celebration of the Supper may be dishonored (Meyer Ed. 3). Among these we may mention a selfish, unloving conduct as one of the chief—such conduct as the rich at Corinth manifested towards the poor, and which exhibited a striking contrast with the love of Christ shown in the sacrifice of Himself for all, and set forth in the Holy Supper wherein the benefits of it are extended to every one.” – Lange’s Commentary

[14] “To eat or drink unworthily is in general to come to the Lord's table in a careless, irreverent spirit, without the intention or desire to commemorate the death of Christ as the sacrifice for our sins, and without the purpose of complying with the engagements which we thereby assume. The way in which the Corinthians ate unworthily was, that they treated the Lord's table as though it were their own; making no distinction between the Lord's supper and an ordinary meal; coming together to satisfy their hunger, and not to feed on the body and blood of Christ; and refusing to commune with their poorer brethren. This, though one, is not the only way in which men may eat and drink unworthily. All that is necessary to observe is, that the warning is directly against the careless and profane, and not against the timid and the doubting.” – Hodge’s Commentary

[15] “The context implies this refers to the disrupted unity of the church caused by the factious groups' arrogance and pride, but some have understood this to refer to the mandate for a proper spiritual attitude when observing the Lord's Supper (cf. Heb. 10:29).” – Bob Utely

[16] “In one sense all Christians are unworthy because they all have and continue to sin. In this context it refers specifically to the disunity and factious spirits of some in the church at Corinth (cf. II Cor. 13:5).” – Bob Utely

[17] "His body" seems not to refer to (1) the physical body of Jesus nor (2) the participants, but to the Church as a group (cf. 10:17; 12:12-13,27). Disunity is the problem. A spirit of superiority or class distinctions destroys the fellowship.” – Bob Utely

[18] “Paul is asserting in plain language that believers who violate the unity of the church may suffer temporal physical consequences, even death (cf. 3:17). This is directly connected to a lack of respect for the body of Christ, the church, the people of God (cf. Acts 5; I  Cor. 5:5; I Tim. 1:20).” – Bob Utely

[19] 'For he who eats and drinks, eats and drinks judgment to himself, if he discern not the body. For this reason many among you are weak and sickly, and not a few sleep.'

For all who come eating and drinking of the Lord's Supper, who do not discern in it His body, and His dying for them, and through it His uniting of them all in His body as one, drink judgment on themselves. Indeed that is why there is sickness among them, and quite a few have died ('sleep' is the Christian synonym for death). This would suggest something unusual which had happened, above the norm, which Paul saw as the chastening of God, for it was not seemingly a judgment that affected their eternal future. It had openly happened, and all were aware of it. It was not theoretical. And it was to be seen as a chastening of the whole church.

“'If he discern not the body.' In chapter 10 stress was laid on the fact that the bread was the representation of the body, and that that included both the body of the Lord Jesus and the body composed of His people as united with Himself. The bread represented His physical body, but it also represented His people made one with Him. Both have to be discerned as one for they are inseparable (Ephesians 2:15-16). Thus as we come to the Lord's Supper we must discern the Lord's body, that is, we must recognise that it proclaims His death for us and that we come as participators in His death and resurrection, and we must equally discern that we are all therefore one body in Christ sharing with Him in His death and resurrection.” – Peter Pett’s Commentary On The Bible

[20] “That there were disorders of the most reprehensible kind among these people at this sacred supper, the preceding verses sufficiently point out; and after such excesses, many might be weak and sickly among them, and many might sleep, i.e. die; for continual experience shows us that many fall victims to their own intemperance. How ever, acting as they did in this solemn and awful sacrament, they might have "provoked God to plague them with divers diseases and sundry kinds of death." (Adam Clarke)

“The “sleepers” had died in the Lord, or this term would not have been used of them; it does not appear that this visitation had singled out the profaners of the sacrament; the community is suffering, for widely-spread offence.”  (Expositors New Testament)