Babylon Is Fallen (Revelation 17-18)

Last week, when we covered the bowl judgments, I said I was going to take the approach that John's vision explains God’s coming judgment on the Roman Empire by taking into the account of the fall of Babylon in light of the defeat of Pharaoh at the Red Sea, and use all of these as framework for a universalized prediction of the judgments that will fall on all Babylons (World Systems) until the final global Babylon is gone when the cup of the global iniquity is full.  

The world of the “earth dwellers”– the corrupt systems that cater to the lust of the flesh, the lust of eyes, and the pride of life[1] – is going to be dismantled and judged, with nations and peoples reaping what they have sown. With that in mind, the next two chapters show the nations of the world bemoaning the loss of Babylon the Great. Two things to remember: 

• The details John describes do not neatly fit any past historical city. It’s not less than Babylon or Rome, but it’s more than just one city. It's the archetypal head of all worldly resistance to God.

• It shows systemic satanic deception and power at a global and national level. I know the idea that there can be “systemic sin” is a debated issue right now, but John sure thought it was a thing. Babylon is the poster child. New Testament scholar Bruce Metzger wrote: “Babylon is allegorical of the idolatry that any nation commits when it elevates material abundance, military prowess, technological sophistication, imperial grandeur, racial pride, and any other glorification of the creature over the Creator... The message of the book of Revelation concerns…God’s judgments not only of persons, but also of nations and, in fact, of all principalities and powers—which is to say, all authorities, corporations, institutions, structures, bureaucracies, and the like.”[2]

Because these chapters are soooo thick with all the same kind of hyperlinks we’ve seen before (Old Testament, historical people and events, Jewish literature), I’m going to let you read through the text and the footnotes included here on your own. We are going to jump to my own paraphrase/version that tries to take all those footnotes into consideration, and then we will discuss a couple key revelations in Revelation J So, let’s skip to page 7.

* * * * * * * * * *

And then one of the seven messengers entrusted with the seven bowls came over to me.[3] Guide: Come, and I will show you the true nature and God’s judgment of the great whore[4] who is sitting on the many waters.[5]  She has seduced all the kings[6] of the earth[7] into committing lewd, sexual acts[8]; and most earth dwellers have become intoxicated[9] with the wine of her harlotry.[10]  Immediately I was in the Spirit, and the guide picked me up and carried me off. In the middle of a vast desert,[11] I saw a woman sitting on a scarlet-colored beast covered with blasphemous names.[12] The beast had seven heads and ten horns like the beast I had seen earlier rising out of the sea. The woman[13] was dressed in purple and scarlet fabrics; she shimmered with gold and jewels and pearls. 

I looked closer and saw that her hand held a golden cup[14] brimming with abominations, bubbling over with the impurities of her sexual exploits. On her forehead was inscribed a name, a mystery[15]: “Babylon the great, the mother of whores and the abominations that defile the earth.”  I looked and saw that the woman was drunk because she had gorged herself on the blood of the saints and the blood of those people who refused to deny Jesus even to save their own lives.[16] When I saw her, I was filled with wonder. 

Guide:  Why are you so amazed? I will reveal to you the mystery of this woman and of the beast with seven heads and ten horns that carries her. The beast you saw was, and is not,[17] and is about to come up out of the abyss and go away into eternal destruction. And the earth dwellers, whose names have not been inscribed in the book of life from the foundation of the world, will be astonished when they see the beast because it was and is not and is to come. Here is the mind possessing wisdom: The seven heads signify the seven mountains[18] where the woman is seated.[19] They also stand for seven kings.  Five have fallen, one is alive, and the last has not yet come to reign.[20] But when he does come, he will be allowed to reign only a short time.[21] Regarding the beast that was and is not, it is actually an eighth ruler[22] that springs from the seven and goes away into eternal destruction.[23]  The ten horns you saw stand for ten kings who have not yet ascended to power, but they will be invested with royal authority for a single hour and will reign together with the beast.[24] These come together for one purpose and one purpose alone: to yield their power and authority to the beast.  Together they will make war on the Lamb, and the Lamb will be victorious over them because He is the Lord over all lords and the King over all kings; and those who stand with Him are called, elect, and faithful. 

 (continuing to speak to me) The waters you saw, where the whore is seated, represent the peoples and multitudes, ethnicities and languages. The beast and the ten horns you saw will despise the whore[25]; they will make her a wasteland and strip her naked.[26] They will gorge themselves on her flesh and incinerate her with fire.[27] For God has placed in their hearts to do what He has purposed, that is, to become one in mind and to surrender their kingdoms over to the beast until the words of God accomplish their end. 18 And the woman you saw—she is the great city that rules over the kings[28] of the earth.[29]

Next I saw another messenger descending from heaven. I knew he possessed great authority because his glory illuminated the earth.  Heavenly Messenger (with a powerful voice): Fallen, fallen, is Babylon[30] the great city![31]It has become a habitat for demons, A haunt for every kind of foul spirit, a prison for every sort of unclean and hateful bird. For all the nations have drunk deeply from the wine of the wrath of her immorality, And the kings of the earth have disgraced themselves by engaging in gross sexual acts with her, and the merchants of the earth have grown fat and rich, profiting off the power purchased with her luxury. 

Then I heard another voice from heaven urge, “My people, get away from her—fast.[32] Make sure you do not get caught up in her sins. Put some distance between you so that you do not share in her plagues, for her sins are higher than the highest mountain. They reach far into the heavens, and God has not forgotten even one of her missteps.”  Deal out to her what she has dealt out to others, and repay her double according to her deeds.[33] In the cup where she mixed her drink, mix her a double.  Whatever glory she demanded and whatever luxury she lived, give back to her the same measure in torment and sorrow. 

Secretly she says in her heart: “I rule as queen; I am not like a widow;[34]
 I will never experience grief.”[35]  Because of this arrogance, in a single day, plagues will overwhelm her. Her portion will be death and sorrow and famine, and she will be incinerated with fire, for mighty is the Lord God who exacts judgment on her. And the kings of the earth, who committed lewd, sexual acts and lived lavishly off of her, will weep and wail over their loss when they see the smoke from her burning body rise into the sky.  They will stand at a distance, fearing they, too, might fall victim to her torment. They will moan,

Woe to you, our great city! Babylon, the most powerful city in the world. In a single hour, your day of judgment has come. And the merchants and the magnates of the earth weep and mourn over her demise because no one is buying their goods any longer:[36]  warehouses remain full of gold, silver, jewels, and pearls; fine fabrics, purple, silk, and scarlet cloth; fragrant woods, items made of ivory, and items finely crafted out of expensive wood; bronze, iron, and marble; cinnamon, spices, incense, myrrh, and frankincense; wine, olive oil, rich flour, and wheat; cattle, sheep, horses, chariots, and human cargo (the trafficked souls of humanity).[37] 

Everything your heart desired has gone away; All the glitz and glitter are lost to you forever; you’ll never have them again! The sellers of these goods, who made a fine profit from her, will stand at a distance. Like the kings, they will fear her punishment might fall on them too. They will weep and mourn their loss. Woe to you, our great city, dressed in finest linens, in purple and scarlet fabrics, dazzling in gold and jewels and pearls. In a single hour, all this wealth is gone. And all the sea captains, all those who sail the seas, sailors, and those who make a living by the sea, stood at a distance. Strong men were reduced to tears as they gazed on the smoke that rose from her ruins. “Was there ever any city like her?” they asked. They threw dust in the air covering their heads. They wept bitterly and mourned their loss. Woe to you, our great city; all who had ships at sea became rich off your wealth! In a single hour, you have been utterly ruined.[38] 

 Rejoice over her torment, O heaven. Join in the celebration, you saints, emissaries, and prophets because God has judged in your favor and against her. Then a mighty messenger picked up a huge stone—it looked like a great millstone—and he cast it into the sea.[39] Mighty Messenger: Watch and see. This is how Babylon, the great city, will be thrown down; violently will she go down, and they will search for her in vain.  Never again will the sound of music grace your streets. The melodies and harmonies of the harpists and musicians and flutists and trumpeters will never be heard again. And never again will an artisan of any craft be found in your markets, And never again will the grinding of the millstone provide rhythm to your city, And never again will the light of a lamp bring warm light to your houses, And never again will the voices of the bridegroom and bride bring joy to your festivities.[40] For the merchants were the magnates of the earth, and all the nations fell prey to your sorceries.[41] And in her streets the blood of the prophets, saints, and all who have been slaughtered upon the earth,[42] ran freely.[43]

* * * * *

 Here begins my paraphrase/ translation - for better or worse :) 

And then one of the seven messengers entrusted with the seven bowls of plagues came over to me. This angel said,“Come, and I will show you the true nature of and God’s judgment on a spiritual prostitute who has seduced all the kings of the earth into the worship of anything but God: money, power, sex, the state, luxury, people, self – anything but God.  These empires offer a system of domination that seduces the powerful, partly with the promise of more power, and intoxicates common people with its alluring false promise of security that supposedly comes from increasing prosperity and power. 

Everyone who loves this world – it’s almost like they have become drunk on sin, addicted to sin on which it is built. They can’t get enough of it.” My guide carried me to the middle of a vast desert, the place where the church fled to get away from Satan’s attacks.

I saw this spiritual prostitute sitting on a beast splattered with the blood of the saints. This 7-headed beast is all the nations and all the rulers of the world, territorially grand and ideologically expansive, creating a compromised but tantalizing blend of politics and religion, and blasphemously self-promoting its own (alleged) grandeur, making claims about itself that are rightly made only about God.

The woman was wearing a headband (as prostitutes are required to do) covered with the names of all the other gods with whom people had been committing spiritual adultery.  The woman appeared beautiful (as all wealthy nations do): she was dressed in stunning robes; she shimmered with gold and jewels and pearls. She looked fine. 

But when I looked more closely, I saw that her hand held a golden cup brimming with poison, with abominations. It was frothing over with the spiritual ooze that follows idolatry. On her forehead, right beside her headband, was inscribed her name, solving the mystery about who she was: “Babylon the great, the mother of idolatry and the abominations that defile all the nations of the earth.” Babylon was drunk with the blood of the saints and the blood of those people who refused to deny Jesus even to save their own lives.  

When I saw her, I was astonished and confused. My guide said, “Let me explain. The beast you saw is all nations that rise up against God - past and present and future. They arise from Satan’s domain and will return to it in the end.  Jesus’ resurrection has ensured their final defeat, but until then they have life, even thought their death is sure.  Those who love earthly nations and worldviews – those whose names have not been inscribed in the book of life - will be mesmerized by all these nations. They will love the greed, exploitation, luxury and idolatry Babylon has to offer them. 

Even though Babylon is seated in power on all of these nations past, present and future, they are all temporary. They all rise only to fall. None of them can last forever. The last of these nations are not yet here, but when they arrive, they will (like the others) be powerful for a limited time as they appear to rule the world.  These nations of the world have one purpose and one purpose alone: to worship and serve the idolatrous goals of the beast.  Together they will make war on God and His Kingdom, but Jesus -  the Lamb who was slain -  will be victorious over them. He is the Lord over all lords and the King over all kings; His called, elect, and faithful will stand with Him. 

 The waters you saw represent the peoples and multitudes, ethnicities and languages.  And the prostitute, Babylon, is a worldview of systemic evil that seduces and then rules over the kings of the earth. But they will eventually plunder and shame her. They will all consume themselves; their sin will spark a fire of judgment and reap an inferno. For God has placed in their hearts to do what He has purposed, that is, to become one in mind and to surrender their kingdoms to evil until the words of God accomplish their end. Remarkably, the idolatrous nations end up undermining the very powers, riches, and privileges they sought. This is how false worship always ends: it is self-destructive through overindulgence and unrestrained oppression and violence. 

When another messenger descended from heaven, I knew he possessed great authority because his glory illuminated the earth. He said with a powerful voice: “Fallen, fallen, is Babylon the great city!  The systems the world held in awe have now become a lifeless wilderness, a habitat for demons and foul spirits, a home for everything unclean and hateful.” This is because all the nations have drunk deeply from the intoxicating wine of violence and greed, and are paying the price.   All the nations have disgraced themselves by joining this idolatry as they were bought with power and enslaved withluxury. The buyers and sellers of decadence and oppression have grown gluttonous, and rich, and cruel.

 Then I heard another voice from heaven say, “My people – followers of the Lamb - get away from Babylon and her nations—fast. Do not get caught up in her sins. Put distance between you so that you do not share in her judgment, because her sins are higher than the highest mountain. They reach far into the heavens like smoke rises from an inferno, and God has not forgotten even one of her missteps. God will deal out to her what she has dealt out to others, and repay her double according to her deeds. In the cup from which she poured our violence and misery, God will mix her a double.  Whatever glory she demanded and in whatever luxury she lived, she will get back the same measure in the torment of justice and the sorrow of guilt and shame that follows sin. 

Secretly she says in her heart: “I rule as a powerful queen; my lovers will never leave me and take away my luxury; I will never experience the grief of loss and need.”  Her addiction to power and comfort leads to arrogant self-sufficiency; the desire to avoid suffering leads to corruption, as anything can be done to keep what she has.   Because of this arrogance, judgment will take her by surprise and overwhelm her. Her life will turn into death and sorrow, and her plenty to famine, and all that she gloried in will disappear like trash incinerated with fire, for mighty is the Lord God who exacts judgment on her. 

And the kings of the earth, her political lovers who committed vile spiritual idolatry with her and lived lavishly off of her, will mourn over their loss when they see the extent of her collapse.  But... they will stand at a distance. They only loved her for what she could do for them. They will be full of fear that they, too, might fall victim to the same torment.  They will moan, “Woe to you, our great city! Babylon, the most powerful city in the world! Your day of judgment has crashed down on you.”  

 And as the economy crashes, and luxury and indulgence disappear, the merchants – the buyers and sellers of things and people -  will weep and mourn over her demise. All their stuff will count as nothing. It will be useless.   Warehouses of luxury goods consumed in acts of conspicuous consumption will remain full of unused and useless gold, silver, jewels, and pearls; fine fabrics, purple, silk, and scarlet cloth; fragrant woods, items made of ivory, and items finely crafted out of expensive wood; bronze, iron, and marble;  cinnamon, spices, incense, myrrh, and frankincense. 

Staples that people need to live - wine, olive oil, flour, and wheat – staples imported in such massive and unnecessary quantities that they left others malnourished and starving - these will be gone. The money and power that follow cattle, sheep, horses, chariots will dry up. Worst is their human cargo- the trafficked bodies and souls of defenseless humanity used, abused and treated like commodities. This, too, will end.

The empire’s elites once got rich and indulgent at the expense of the rest of the empire and indeed the world; now, everything their hearts desire has gone away; all the glitz and glitter are lost forever. The sellers of these goods, who made a fine profit from selling them to Babylon, will stand at a distance.  Like the kings, they will fear her punishment might fall on them too. They will weep and mourn the loss of the city that made their extravagance possible. “Woe to you, our great city, dressed in finest linens, in purple and scarlet fabrics, dazzling in gold and jewels and pearls. Your empire of wealth has collapsed.”  

And all the movers and shakers of this oppressive economic system that abused and consumed things and people alike will keep their distance as well.  Men thought of as strong (by beastly standards) will be reduced to tears as they gaze on the smoke that rose from her ruins. “Was there ever such a glorious human city like this one?” they will ask as  they weep bitterly and mourn their loss.“Woe to you, our great city; all who trafficked things and people became so rich off your wealth! Now, you have crumbled.”

But these economic and political titans of the earth?  They were deceived and corrupted. All the nations fell prey to Babylon’s poisonous seduction. And it was in Babylon’s streets that people paid the price: the blood of the prophets, saints – indeed, all whose lives have been pillaged - ran freely. Empires will eventually resort to anything necessary, including lethal violence, to silence the pro-God, counter-cultural witness of the faithful. Their economic, physical, emotional, and spiritual suffering filled the gutters of the cruel world.

O heaven, rejoice when you see justice roll down, because it means God has been victorious. Join in the celebration, you saints, emissaries, and prophets because God has judged in favor of the followers of the Lamb and against the followers of Babylon and Rome.

Then a mighty messenger picked up what looked like a huge millstone and he cast it into the sea. The messenger said, “Watch and see. This is how Babylon, the great city, will be thrown down; violently will she go down, and they will never find her again. Do you remember when Jeremiah prophesied God’s judgment on Jerusalem? It will happen again, but this time to the Babylons of the world: No more celebratory music, because there will be nothing to celebrate; no more marketplace hubs of community life, there is no community when there is no unity; food and fuel will be scarce, as consumers and hoarders and users care only for themselves; even the closest of human relationships will fall by the wayside. And thus Babylon will fall. 

Empires often eventually die of  self-inflicted wounds; their subjects revolt and destroy the very thing that has empowered them; this reversal is, in a very real sense, the judgment of God. [44] 

* * * * *

The “Babylon/Rome” societies mentioned in Scripture have certain common characteristics:

• Overabundance, and luxury accumulated at the expense of others (Jer 51:13; Eze 16:13, 49; Na 2:9; Rev 18:3, 7, 16-17). It’s when the love of money becomes the root of all kinds of evil: exploitation, greed, the commodification of people.

• Arrogance, self-trust and boastfulness (Isa 14:12-14; Jer 50:31; Eze 16:15, 50, 56; 27:3; 28:5; cf. Rev 18:7). Even the most powerful nations who say, “I rule the world,” and whom people say, “Who is like her?” are going to fall. 

• The use of power and violence against God’s image bearers and children (Jer 51:35, 49; Eze 23:37; Na 3:1-3; cf. Rev 18:10, 24). Ninevah was judged for violence against image bearers; Egypt for violence against God’s people. All the spilled blood of the innocent cries out to God.[45]

• Oppression and injustice (Isa 14:4; Eze 16:49; 28:18; cf. Rev 18:5, 20). Unfair courts, corrupt legal, political and economic systems.

• Idolatry (Jer 51:47; Eze 16:17, 36; 23:7, 30, 49; Na 1:14; cf. Rev 17:4-5; 18:3; 19:2)[46]Think specifically of emperor worship (as we saw in the 7 letters) which tried to make Christ subservient to Caesar. Nations will seek to make the state or its political leaders the source of hope and trust, the thing that demands our allegiance even if it puts us at odds with our faith.

 In summary: We see an arrogant international economic power with clients around the world, hostile to the path and people of God, engaged in the uncontrolled pursuit of luxury, with commerce that even includes trading in human beings, and with a willingness to use violence and exploitation to keep its comfort and power. That’s…all nations, given enough time.[47]

Revelation is a sustained stripping of the sacred from secular power—military, political, economic—and a parallel sustained recognition of God and the Lamb as the rightful bearers of sacred claims. [48] Revelation is a summons to uncivil worship and witness.

John is calling followers of Jesus to choose allegiance to Babylon or to Christ. We choose either Heavenly Kingdom or Earthly Empire. Christians must “come out” – that is, withdraw their support of and participation in – from any nation, party or leader who demands an almost worshipful loyalty and adulation. The Cross must always stand higher than the flag.[49]

Let’s pull from today’s headlines just to see the timelessness of John’s warning. The Jerusalem Post published an article this week that I think is worth noting. It’s called “Ukrainian religious leaders liken Putin to anti-Christ, Hitler.”[50] 

The spokesman of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine had harsh words for Russian President Vladimir Putin calling him the anti-Christ and likening him to Nazi leader Adolf Hitler. “Putin is really not messiah, but really anti-Christ of our current time,” Yevstratiy Zoria, the spokesman for the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, said on the BBC Global News Podcast. “He is anti-Christ because everything what he does, everything what he do now, is totally against gospel, against God’s law.”Zoria’s statement followed that of Metropolitan Epiphanius I of Ukraine who said on Sunday that “the spirit of the anti-Christ operates in the leader of Russia.” 

“The spirit of the antichrist operates in the leader of Russia, the signs of which the Scriptures reveal to us: pride, devotion to evil, ruthlessness, false religiosity. This was Hitler during World War II. This is what Putin has become today.” While these statements serve to highlight a religious conflict between the Orthodox churches of Russia and Ukraine, Putin – though seemingly secular – has not shied away from using religion in his political quests. In his latest nonfiction book, Enemies and Allies, Evangelical author Joel C. Rosenberg explored how religion factors into Putin’s politics. 

“Putin… claims to be a Christian, occasionally attends the Russian Orthodox Church, poses for photo ops with Orthodox priests, and refers in speeches to the church and its importance in Russian life more than any Russian leader since the days of the czars. But there is no evidence that he has a personal relationship with Jesus Christ or that the teaching of the Bible actually shapes or guides his actions. Rather, the evidence suggests Putin is playing on the deep cultural and nationalistic affection the Russian people have for the Russian Orthodox Church to advance his popularity and political power."

[An article] in The Heritage Foundation argued that “Putin often invokes the Russian Orthodox Church in his public speeches, giving the church a much more prominent place in Russian political life than under his predecessors. But these invocations hardly seem sincere in the religious sense. Rather, he has used the church to justify Russian expansion...” Bishop of Leeds, Nick Baines [noted] that Putin has been encouraged by the Russian Orthodox Church to invade Ukraine. The Church, he said, has bought into the "mythology," which Putin believes, that Russia and Ukraine belong together – Ukraine is a fake country.

 Or, from Christianity Today, in an article entitled “Hundreds of Russian Pastors Oppose War In Ukraine.” 

Ukrainian evangelicals have had enough. Battered by a week of war, they have heard numerous prayers for peace uttered by their Russian colleagues. But they did not hear condemnation. “Your unions have congratulated Putin, giving thanks for freedom of belief,” said Taras Dyatlik, the Overseas Council regional director for Eastern Europe and Central Asia. “The time has come to make use of that freedom.” 

“Remember Mordechai and Esther,” he wrote March 1 in an open letter. “Do not be like Jehoshaphat, who entered into an alliance with Ahab, and was silent when God spoke through the prophet Micaiah.” Dyatlik accused his Russian colleagues of buying into national rhetoric—first in 2014, when Russian-backed forces invaded the eastern region of Donbas—and again today. But “begging on my knees,” he leveraged his reputation with the heads of Russia’s evangelical unions—while acknowledging their difficult reality. “You fear prison,” he said. “[But] do not be faithful to Putin. Be faithful to the body of Christ.”

Oh, friends. We must be careful. The Russian church is not uniquely susceptible to this kind of deception. Christians who were, and are, and are to come will live in Babylons that look good, but in whose hand is a bowl full of abominations. Russian Christians are not unique in being deceived by how national leaders paint the world; Russian Christians are no unique in needing to fight the tendency to compromise for the sake of economic, physical or spiritual comfort. Russian Christians are not unique in tarnishing their legacy over the pursuit of or alignment with state power. This is as old as Revelation.  

"Come out of her, my people." 

(Jeremiah 50:8; 51:6-9; Isaiah 48:20; 52:11; 2 Corinthians 6:17).

Christians are to flee, to separate themselves ideologically and spiritually from all the forms of Babylon. If we "share in her sins," we will share in her sufferings. This warning is addressed to professing Christians. We must be wise.[51] I want to talk next week about how we do this pointedly and purposefully. I leave you with this as prep.

The task of a witness is to speak courageously in word and deed, testifying to the truth of God and prophesying against all falsehood that distorts and parodies divine truth.  

Witnesses offer testimony to the vision of God given them in the hope that others will repent from error and turn to the truth, but their success is measured, not by the quantity of their converts, but by the steadfastness of their testimony.  

This suggests that the church should be missional and prophetic, a martyrological community, a gathering of witnesses. Such a calling is difficult and dangerous, but it carries with it the promise of God’s protection in the present and God’s reward in the future.[52]

_____________________________________________________________________

[1] 1 John 2:16

[2] Reading Revelation Responsibly, Michael Gorman

[3] “Many believe that chapter 17 describes religious Babylon and chapter 18 the commercial aspect.” (Believer’s Bible Commentary)

[4] Jezebel in 2:20–23 was a key seducer akin to Babylon the prostitute (2:21, 22; cf. 17:2). In the Bible, harlotry frequently symbolizes apostasy and idolatry (see Is 1:21; 23:15; Jer 13:25–27; Ezk 16; Hos 4:12; Nah 3:4). (Orthodox Study Bible) “The best background for understanding the language of the chapter is… the descriptions of Jerusalem as the harlot in Eze 16 and 23 and Babylon as the harlot in Jer 51.” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[5] Come, I will show you the punishment of the great prostitute. Introduces the theme of ch. 17 and contrasts with 21:9(“Come, I will show you the bride”). (NIV Biblical Theology Study Bible)

[6] “Some Jewish prophecies complain about Rome’s drunken weddings with her suitors, the kings of the East she was seducing.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[7]  “Both the kings of the earth and the inhabitants of the earth are seduced into committing spiritual adultery with Babylon. The indication is that she made them drunk with power, material possessions, false worship, and pride.” (NKJV Study Bible)

[8] “Nineveh, the capital of the evil Assyrian empire, seduced the nations with her prostitution and witchcraft (Nah 3.4)” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[9] Seducing the nations into idolatry, likely through the empty promise of political power and especially economic gain (cf. 18:2–19) (NIV Biblical Theology Study Bible)

[10] “Because Babylon is the city responsible for the destruction of Jerusalem’s first temple in 586 b.c., John uses this ominous symbol to describe the Babylon of his day—Rome, the city on seven hills… Its beauty and power are legendary, but beneath the surface lies the truth of its nature. What Rome represents in John’s day has been replicated by many different world powers and their material attractions.”  (The Voice Commentary)

[11] Why in the desert, when she usually sits on many waters? “Since the woman who gave birth to the Child-Ruler fled into the wilderness as a place of protection (12:6, 14), perhaps Babylon here is seen as being in league with the dragon and the beast as they ferociously pursue God’s people (12:13–16).” (NKLV Study Bible) On the other hand, Believer’s Bible Commentary thinks this is an apostate church. Primasius said it was “the absence of God, for his presence is paradise.”

[12] “Full of blasphemous names.” These are spiritual competitors, the names of the gods and the other nations. (Michael Heisser)

[13] “Gentiles often personified their homeland as a woman, or the city as a wealthy goddess enthroned beside a river.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[14] Jeremiah 51:7

[15] “Roman law stated harlots must wear headbands exhibiting their name. This great harlot bears the mysterious name of BABYLON . . . MOTHER OF HARLOTS. For the late-first-century Christians, Babylon was incarnate in Rome (see 1Pt 5:13), but it is primarily a spiritual reality, a “mystery,” transcending concrete manifestations. (Orthodox Study Bible)

[16] Condemnations of Babylon and Tyre (Jer. 50; 51; Ezek. 27) (ESV Reformation Study Bible)

[17] “The play here on the tenses "was . . . is not . . . will come" refers to a three-stage history of the beast… That John's beast "is not" refers to his defeat by the Lamb on Calvary (cf. Jn 12:31-32)… all other gods are nothing or nonexistent (1Co 8:4-6). Satan once had unchallenged power over the earth ("was," cf. Lk 4:6; Heb 2:14-15). Yet he is given a "little time" to oppose God and his people (12:12c; 13:5; 20:3b) before his final sentencing to "destruction" (v.11; cf. Mt 7:13; Jn 17:12; Ro 9:22; 2Th 2:3). It is this apparent revival of Satan's power and authority over the world after his mortal wound (Ge 3:15) that causes the deceived of earth to follow him.” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[18] “An ancient seal showing a seven-headed chaos monster being slain illustrates John's imagery. In that scene, the monster is being slain by a progressive killing of its heads. Four of the heads are dead…Yet the chaos monster is still active because three heads still live. Similarly, John's message is that five of the monster's heads are already defeated (12:11). One head is now active, thus showing the reality of the beast's contemporary agents who afflict the saints; and one head remains, indicating that the battle will soon be over but not with the defeat of the contemporary evil agents. “(Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[19] Ancient writers commonly referred to Rome as the city on seven hills. However, “In the seven other instances in Revelation, the word for "hills" here is always rendered "mountains," which are world powers (Isa 2:2; Jer 51:25; Da 2:35; Zec 4:7). It seems better, then, to interpret the seven mountains as a reference to the seven heads or kings, which describe not the city but the beast.” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[20] “Seven mountains may also refer to successive world empires (see Ps. 30:7; Jer. 51:25; Dan. 2:44, 45).“ (NKJV Study Bible)

[21] “These five may be the first five Roman emperors, beginning with Julius Caesar with the being Nero. The five might simply represents an indefinite number of previous persecuting states, with the sixth indicating Christians are near the end.” (ESV Reformation Study Bible)

[22] So much speculation here. Most agree: it’s the final ruler before God wraps up history.

[23] “Of the three stages of the beast—was, is not, will come—only the last is related to his coming "up out of the Abyss" (v.8)…  Christ has killed the monster by his death (Ge 3:15; Rev 12:7-9) and for believers he "is not" (has no power), yet the beast still has life ("one is" [v.10]) and will attempt one final battle… and will give the appearance that he is alive and in control of the world (cf. Lk 4:5-7). That beast belongs to the seven qualitatively (he is of the same quality)." (Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[24] “The number “ten” goes back through v. 7 and 13:1 to Dan. 7:7, 24… the beast has characteristics of all four of Daniel’s beasts.” (ESV Reformation Study Bible)  “May designate the ten provincial governors of Rome, Rome’s client kings from conquered territories, or the “the kings of the earth” (v. 18; cf. 16:14)” (NIV Biblical Theology Study Bible)

[25] “A prostitute’s former lovers might betray her (Lam 1.2), strip her (Ezek 16.39; 23.26–29) or even kill her (Jer 4.30). In the OT God stripped his people (Jer 13.22, 26–27; Ezek 16.37), Nineveh (Nah 3.5) and Babylon (Isa 47.3)” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[26] “Evil will turn against evil as the beast and its “ten horns” will destroy Babylon, the idolatrous economic system that supports them. They despise, shamefully expose, and burn Babylon (cf. Isa 47:1–14), which also recalls the judgment against apostate Israel (cf. Ezek 16:35–42; 23:28–30).” (NIV Biblical Theology Study Bible)

[27] “The lesson from Roman times can be generalized: idolatrous states end up destroying the very powers, riches, privileges, and people that they originally supported. False worship is self-destructive.” (ESV Reformation Study Bible)

[28] “By this period people in the empire spoke of Rome as the city that ruled land and sea to the ends of the earth.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[29] “When John’s prophecy will be fulfilled, an amazing thing will happen: The harlot will be made desolate by the very system that carried her.” (NKJV Wiersbe Study Bible)

[30] “’Babylon’ means ‘confusion’…It signifies people who are arrogant, robbers, dissolute and impious, and who persevere in their wickedness.” Caesarius of Arles

[31] Likely inspired by Is 13:19–22; 34:11–15

[32] “Separation is a refusal to participate in the works of darkness (2Co 6:14–18).” (Orthodox Study Bible)

[33] Double payment was exacted from a thief (Ex 22.4, 7, 9), and from God’s people (Isa 40.2; Jer 16.18). Babylon would drink from “the cup she mixed” (cf. Rev 14.8–10; Isa 51.22–23; Jer 50.29; Ob 15). (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[34] See Isaiah 47 for background imagery here.

[35] Babylon's sin is described as satiety ("luxury"), pride ("boasts, I sit as a queen"), and avoidance of suffering ("I will never mourn"). Luxury leads to boastful self-sufficiency (Eze 28:5); the desire to avoid suffering leads to the dishonest pursuit of luxury (Eze 28:18). 

[36] This is Roman merchandise. (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[37] “Most items on the list are luxury goods, symbols of conspicuous consumption; some are basic staples, such as wheat, but imported in such massive quantities that residents of Rome ate free while many peasants in Egypt, where much of the grain was grown, were malnourished. The list climaxes with “human lives” sold as slaves (v. 13)—the gravest injustice of the empire (cf. Deut 24.7)… Rome’s rich indulged themselves at the expense of the rest of the empire.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[38] Reminscent of Eze 27, a lamentation over the fall of Tyre. 

[39] “God commanded Jeremiah to hurl a stone into the middle of the Euphrates to symbolize the permanent fall of Babylon (Jer 51.63–64). Revelation amplifies the image as a millstone thrown into the sea, probably recalling Jesus’ warning in Mark 9.42 and Luke 17.2.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)

[40] “When God judged Judah by means of Babylon, Jerusalem became desolate, without lighted lamps or the sounds of millstones or the joyful sound of newlyweds (Jer 25.10; cf. Jer 16.9). Now Babylon reaps what it sowed.” (NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible) 

[41] Nahum’s prophecy against Nineveh mentions “the prostitute, gracefully alluring, mistress of sorcery, who enslaves nations through her debaucheries and peoples through her sorcery” (Nah 3.4).

[42] “The great sin of Babylon is cited. She has martyred the prophets and followers of Jesus. John has already mentioned this blood-guiltiness (17:6; cf. 19:2). Elsewhere the death of martyrs is attributed to "the inhabitants of the earth" (6:10), the "beast that comes up from the Abyss" (11:7, 13:7), and the "beast, coming out of the earth" (13:15). In v.24 "the blood . . . of all who have been killed on the earth" refers to all those who have been martyred because of their loyalty to the true God. Once again, in John's mind, Babylon the Great encompasses all the persecution against the servants of God until his words are fulfilled (cf. 17:17).” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary)

[43] Note also the many allusions to Jer. 50; 51and Ezek. 27.

[44] Several paragraphs from Reading Revelation Responsibly, by Michael Gorman, were woven into this.

[45] Deuteronomy 32:33

[46] This list from NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible

[47] Dragons, John, and Every Grain of Sand: Essays on the Book of Revelation. Edited by Shane wood.

[48] Ibid

[49] Asbury Bible Commentary

[50] https://www.jpost.com/christianworld/article-699171

[51] Expositor’s Bible Commentary

[52] Reading Revelation Responsibly, Michael Gorman

An Interlude: Revelation 14

We are getting into the part of Revelation where your eschatology (view of the End Times) is going to have a big impact on how you interpret what is happening. I mentioned in Message+ last week that you are probably not going to hear me land on any one view. I’m going to try to get to the underlying truths that are present no matter the view. 

The Song of the 144,000

Then I looked, and here was the Lamb standing on Mount Zion, and with him were 144,000, who had his name and his Father’s name[1] written on their foreheads.  I also heard a sound coming out of heaven like the sound of many waters and like the sound of loud thunder.[2] 

Zion

• In Psalm 76  Zion symbolizes the defeat of God's enemies and the salvation of his people.

• Zion is the entire city of Jerusalem (Isaiah 4:3–4; 52:1–2) or the temple mount, considered the dwelling place of God 

• In Hebrews, Zion is viewed as a heavenly city where God, angels, and the church reside (12:22–23; also 2 Esdras 2:42), and Christ has begun his messianic reign (Psalm 2:6).[3]

• The 144,000 are destined for the celestial city with a wall of 144 cubits (21.16–17),[4]suggesting Zion here could be the church.[5]

 So is it a geographic location, a symbol for heavenly realities, the church? Sure - as long as the conclusion is that the crucified and resurrected Lamb is enthroned, and those who follow him repeat His victory over the dragon and the beast by following the commandments of God and holding fast to the testimony of Jesus 

Now the sound I heard was like that made by harpists playing their harps, and they were singing a new song before the throne and before the four living creatures and the elders. No one was able to learn the song except the 144,000 who had been redeemed from the earth.

This is a new song of redemption[6] sung by those who have been redeemed.[7] It is a hymn to the Lamb (Christ) who has inaugurated the new age (see also 21:1, 5), rescuing people by his death so that they could participate in God’s purposes as ‘kings and priests’ in the world. No one else can sing it, not even the 4 living creatures and the elders: they aren’t human beings who have experienced the glorious redemption Jesus provides.  

[The 144,000] are the ones who have not defiled themselves with women, for they are virgins. These are the ones who follow the Lamb wherever he goes. These were redeemed from humanity as firstfruits to God and to the Lamb, and no lie was found on their lips; they are blameless.[8] 

The 144,000

Numbers in Revelation are weighed rather than counted; I suspect a lot of descriptions are the same – they should be treated as symbols rather than literal descriptions. Revelation is apocalyptic literature, and pretty much everything is an icon we click to take us to a deeper reality. 

• The 144,000 males were first introduced in Revelation 7:4 as "sons of Israel."[9]  We talked then about it being a census for the mustering of an army. A battle is going on in Revelation; these are the people who signed up.

• Taken literally, it’s 144,000 male virgins. So the ability to follow the Lamb wherever he goes would be limited to 144,000 men who have not had sex.  Since the Bible nowhere else suggests that having sex ruins the holiness of a person,[10] I’m going to opt for seeing this as a symbolic group. What does virginity symbolize?

• The 7 churches were not to cheat with Jezebel or "Babylon the Great, the Mother of Prostitutes" (17:5), who "made all the nations drink the maddening wine of her adulteries"(14:8; compare 17:1-6). They have not defiled themselves through spiritual fornication. Paul once wrote, "I promised you to one husband, to Christ, so that I might present you as a pure virgin to him" (2 Corinthians 11:2).

• Communities are personified as women in Revelation: the church is a mother (chap. 12), Babylon is a prostitute (chap. 17), the church is a bride (chap. 21). Personifying redeemed individuals as male and redeemed communities as female says nothing about their actual gender. [11]

 So this group should be weighed. It’s a group of faithful followers of Jesus[12] who are the firstfruits…..

Firstfruits

“Firstfruits” point toward the much greater harvest to come (think of the first portions of the harvest given as an offering to God in Exodus 23:16 and Nehemiah 10:35, for example. A couple examples:

• Paul used ‘firstfruits’ to describe Israel as the spiritual root of the church (Rom. 11:16), as did James (1:18) and Jeremiah (2:3)[13] 

• Paul described his first converts in Asia and Achaia as the ‘firstfruits’ (Romans 16:5; 1 Corinthians 16:15)

• James said that God “gave us birth by the word of truth so that we would be a kind of firstfruits of his creatures.” (James 1:18)

• “But Christ has indeed been raised from the dead, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep… For as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive.  But each in turn: Christ, the firstfruits; then, when he comes, those who belong to him.” (1 Cor. 5: 20-23) 

 John presents the 144,000 as the first installment of redeemed humanity,[14] along with the "great multitude that no one could count" from 7:9-17.[15]  This is sometimes seen as those redeemed from Israel (the faithful remnant[16]), and then the multitude of Gentile converts. However you want to parse that out, it’s faithful followers of Jesus whose entrance into heaven is the beginning of a much greater harvest.

So far…. Jesus is enthroned; the faithful, the firstfruits of the redeemed, are having a glorious time. 

Three Angels and Three Messages

Then I saw another angel flying directly overhead, and he had an eternal gospel[17] to proclaim to those who live on the earth—to every nation, tribe, language, and people.  He declared in a loud voice: “Fear God and give him glory, because the hour of his judgment has arrived, and worship the one who made heaven and earth, the sea and the springs of water!” 

A second angel followed the first, declaring: “Fallen, fallen is Babylon the great city![18] She made all the nations drink of the wine of her immoral passion.” 

 A third angel followed the first two, declaring in a loud voice: “If anyone worships the beast and his image, and takes the mark on his forehead or his hand, that person will also drink of the wine of God’s anger that has been mixed undiluted in the cup of his wrath, and he will be tortured with fire and sulfur in front of the holy angels and in front of the Lamb.[19]   

And the smoke[20] from their torture will go up forever and ever, and those who worship the beast and his image will have no rest day or night, along with anyone who receives the mark of his name.” 

This requires  the steadfast endurance of the saints—those who obey God’s commandments and hold to their faith in Jesus.  Then I heard a voice from heaven say, “Write this: ‘Blessed are the dead, those who die in the Lord from this moment on!’” Yes,” says the Spirit, “so they can rest from their hard work, because their deeds will follow them.”

Then I looked, and a white cloud appeared, and seated on the cloud was one like a son of man! [21] He had a golden crown on his head and a sharp sickle in his hand. Then another angel came out of the temple, shouting in a loud voice to the one seated on the cloud, “Use your sickle and start to reap, because the time to reap has come, since the earth’s harvest is ripe!” So the one seated on the cloud swung his sickle over the earth, and the earth was reaped.

 Then another angel came out of the temple in heaven, and he too had a sharp sickle.  Another angel, who was in charge of the fire, came from the altar and called in a loud voice to the angel who had the sharp sickle, “Use your sharp sickle and gather the clusters of grapes off the vine of the earth, because its grapes are now ripe.” 

So the angel swung his sickle over the earth and gathered the grapes from the vineyard of the earth and tossed them into the great winepress of the wrath of God.[22]  Then the winepress was stomped outside the city, and blood poured out of the winepress up to the height of horses’ bridles for a distance of almost 200 miles.[23]

Judgment

Those who drink Babylon's wine cup of idolatry will eventually drink the cup of God’s wrath.[24] Considering that during this time God’s people are called to “patient endurance,” and that later we will see this cup is filled with the blood of the martyrs, I tend to see the primary (though not only) reason for God’s anger as the killing of his children.[25]  Those who poured out the blood of His people will reap what they have sown; [26] “Those who live by the sword will die by the sword.”[27] What was planted will be harvested. 

Apparently – since this cup is unmixed - the cup of God’s wrath is usually diluted. I think (?) this means that throughout human history, God has diluted the full strength of judgment. He has not intervened as maximally as He justly could have: 

• Egypt (though idolatrous) could have avoided God’s anger and carried on if they hadn’t enslaved God’s people. 

• God could have destroyed violent Ninevah instead of warning them about the upcoming punishment for their violence.

• The nations Israel fought in Canaan had to have “their cups full” of evil doing before God brought judgment to them. 

Historically, God let cups get pretty full before people drank the wine of their own brewing. Eventually, “the time has come to destroy those who destroy the earth” (Revelation 11:18). It’s grim. 

“thoroughly corrupt, totally degenerate; waste away by the decaying influence of moral (spiritual) impurity; utterly corrupt; becoming morally depraved all the way through’ (‘utterly decayed’).”  (HELPS Word Studies)

 As they did unto others, it will be done unto them. They corrupted others; they encouraged them toward depravity; they decayed them. God will make Babylon drink her own mixture, experienced as the wine of his wrath in retribution for her immoral deeds.[28]  [29] [30]  One of the most sobering things God can do is “give them over to themselves” (Romans 1).[31] We’ll see this later when the nations mourn that Babylon the Great has fallen even while they are the one tearing her apart.  

The wording of ‘those who worship the beast’ suggests not only that they worship the beast, but they “persist in worshipping him, even to the end. This characteristic is so strongly marked that they are here represented as keeping it even after their death."[32] Sometimes we get what we want - and it’s a terrible thing.[33] 

[Babylon’s] sins are piled up to heaven, and God has remembered her crimes. Give back to her as she has given; pay her back double for what she has done. Pour her a double portion from her own cup... God has judged her with the judgment she imposed on you.” (Revelation 18:5-6; 20)”[34]

Now, to the bloody imagery. This was how people of that time consistently described times of judgment and death.

• Ancient descriptions of wars spoke of rivers flowing with blood. 

• Blood obstructed ships; trees dripped with gore dropped on them when satiated birds grew weary of feasting on corpses. 

•  In 1Enoch, sinners’ blood covers chariots; horses walk up to their chests in the blood. 

•  rabbis lamented horses drowning in blood and blood rolling huge boulders 40 miles out to the sea.[35] 

This passage says blood will stretch out for 200 miles - on a flat plain. It’s clearly not literal.  It is, however, devastating and final.

Fire and Smoke[36]

Throughout Revelation, fire has been a symbol of judgment: 1:14, 2:18, 3:18, 4:3, 8:5, 15:2, 19:12.[37]  The language is drawn from the description of the overthrow of the cities of the plain under the rain of brimstone and fire; cf. Gen. 19:24, 28; Isa. 34:9 f.; Jude 7.[38]  It also draws from Isaiah 34:9-10, the judgment of Edom:

Edom’s… dust will turn to brimstone, and the land will ignite with burning pitch. Edom’s fiery judgment will burn day and night for all time; the smoke from it will ascend forever.[39] For generations to come it will be a wasteland, and no person will make it their home ever again…When God measures the land, desolation will be its width and chaos will mark its length. (Isaiah 34)

Notice what the fire does and for what the smoke stands as a memorial: utter desolation and chaos (or emptiness, as some translations say). And this note of desolation, chaos and emptiness brings us to our final point.  

Rest vs. Restlessness (for their deeds will follow them)

In Revelation 6:11, the souls of the martyrs were told to "wait" (literally "rest") until their number was complete. In both passages those who die in Christ are said to be at rest, in contrast to the worshipers of the beast, for whom "there is no rest day or night" forever (14:11).[40] “Those who worship the beast and his image….have no rest day and night” is an almost verbatim repetition of how the cherubim worship God in heaven.[41]

While the Bible uses vivid imagery to describe hell as a place you don’t want to go and heaven as a place you do, the role of rest stands out to me in this particular passage. The Bible is thick with the discussion of rest.

•  Ex. 33:14 And he said, “My presence will go with you, and I will give you rest.”

• Jeremiah 6:16  “Thus says the Lord: ‘Stand by the roads, and look, and ask for the ancient paths, where the good way is; and walk in it, and find rest for your souls.’”

• Psalm 116:7  “Return, O my soul, to your rest; for the Lord has dealt bountifully with you.”

• Jer. 31:25  “I will satisfy the weary soul, and every languishing soul I will replenish.”

• Matthew 11:28-29 “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.[42] Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls.”

• Matthew 12:43; Luke 11:24 “When an unclean spirit comes out of a man, it passes through arid places seeking rest[43] and does not find it.”

• 1 Corinthians 16: 17-18 “I rejoice at the coming of [a few dudes]; they have made up for your absence, for they have refreshed[44] my spirit and yours.”

• Philemon 1:7; 20  “Your love has given me much joy and comfort, my brother, for your kindness has often refreshed[45] the hearts of God’s people... Yes, brother, let me have some benefit and joy from you in the Lord; refresh my heart in Christ.”

• Hebrews 4:9-11  “There still remains a place of rest, a true Sabbath, for the people of God because those who enter into salvation’s rest lay down their labors in the same way that God entered into a Sabbath rest from His. So let us move forward to enter this rest, so that none of us fall into the kind of faithless disobedience that prevented them from entering.”

 If the righteous rest from their hard work because their deeds will follow them, then the unrighteous can’t rest, because their deeds have followed them also. 

“But the wicked are like the storm-tossed sea, for it cannot be still, and its waves churn up mire and muck.” (Isaiah 57:20)

What if, in the next life, we have chosen a path to a place where our wants and needs and desires are never satisfied? What if we can never rest?  

• That affirmation we crave? Never happens. 

• That sense of self-worth? Eternally elusive. 

• The pleasure of actually feeling good enough? Never felt. 

• Rest from needing to earn the love or admiration of others? Failure after failure. 

• The desire to be seen and known? Not going to happen in a world of the relationally blind. 

• Moments of tranquility and peace? Ever elusive. 

• Being loved? Never. 

• The relentless, addictive nature of sin? Unrelenting. 

• The gnawing sense that there is another person who can make me happier than the one I am with, another job that will fulfill me, another house in which I will be happy, another vacation that will finally relax me…. “How much money does it take to make a man happy? Just one more dollar.” — John D. Rockefeller.

• The despair of hopelessness? Every present. 

• Every increasing cravings with ever diminishing returns? Constant.[46]

“Our heart is restless until it find its rest in thee.” – Augustine

That is in sharp contrast with those who have rest. The deeds that followed them were that they kept God’s commandments and clung to the testimony of Jesus.  There is a Someone standing between us and that curse. The trajectory of a life that finds its fulfillment in Christ in the end has already begun.  We find rest now when… 

• we accept that Jesus affirms our status as image bearers and children with dignity and worth. We don’t have to earn that; God has given us that

• we realize Jesus grounds our identity in Him as redeemed and made holy when Jesus gave us love simply because He loved us; we don’t have to be good enough to be loved; we are loved because God is good enough to love even us. 

• we accept that Jesus fully know us and fully loves us; nothing is hidden, yet grace is still offered

• we experience the peace of God keeping our hearts and minds in the storms of life; they may be hard, but we are never alone 

• we discover that Jesus is enough to satisfy us in the midst of our lack – his grace is sufficient for us even when stuff around us crumbles

• the light of the empty grave illuminates the darkness at the end of our despairing tunnels. 

 There will be a day – the ‘not yet’ -  when everything that we experienced in part we will experience in whole as we drink fully from the cup of the love of Jesus.  

 _______________________________________________________________________________

[1] The names written on the foreheads fulfills the promise given to the victors (3:12). 

[2] The sounds of judgment. We’ve heard this sound several times already in Revelation.

[3] Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary of the New Testament

[4] NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible

[5] Orthodox Study Bible

[6] This song was sung in Chapter 5 also.

[7] Zondervan Bible Commentary (One Volume)

[8] In contrast to the Beast and those who follow it, who spew lies.

[9] Well, not Dan, but Levi steps in to take Dan’s place. It’s complicated.

[10] See Song of Songs. Sex was God’s idea. He intends for it to be a wondrous thing within His design.  

[11] IVP New Testament Commentary Series

[12] The Lamb was first seen as if "slain" or "slaughtered" (5:6), and to follow the Lamb wherever he goes is to be "slain" as he was and for his sake (6:9), [12] suggesting the 144,000 are martyrs (6:11). This seems to suggest (?) the song may be even more specific than simply the song of redeemed: it may be that those who have given their lives for the sake of their faith have had such a terrible experience on earth transformed into a uniquely glorious experience in heaven. 

[13] Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary of the New Testament

[14] Zondervan Bible Commentary (One Volume)

[15] IVP New Testament Commentary Series

[16] Isaiah 10:20, Jeremiah 31:7, Micah 2:12 and Zephaniah 3:13

[17] Reminder: it was said that Augustus “was the beginning for the world of the good tidings (euangeliōn; gospel) that came by reason of him.” This directly challenges that claim notion: it is God who is the source of euangelion,not the emperor. The angel flying in mid-heaven seems to correspond with Matthew 24:14: “And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in all the world as a witness to all the nations, and then the end will come.” Expositor's Bible Commentary (Abridged Edition): New Testament

[18] “Fallen, fallen is Babylon the great…” is from Isaiah 21:9, which adds, “and all the carved images of her gods [God] has shattered to the ground.” In Daniel 2, the kingdom made without hands is the kingdom of God that shatters the other kingdoms. This was inaugurated by Jesus. Its inevitable demise is now in progress. Again, this is the “already, but not yet” sort of thing that you see going on in the New Testament. (Michael Heisser)

[19] This suggests this is still part of temporal judgment rather than eternal. There is no other indication in Scripture that those in eternity with Jesus are aware of what is happening to those who are not. 

[20] In Chapter 7, the smoke is “the prayers of the saints.”  In Chapter 15, the temple is filled with the smoke of God’s glory and power. There is something about the smoke that is an icon for a message ‘behind’ the smoke. 

[21] “The language is derived from Dan. 7:13 (and Rev. 1:13).

[22] Wine was sometimes called the “blood of grapes” (Gen 49.11) NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible

[23] Writing against the background of America's own Civil War bloodbath, Julia Ward Howe captured something of the spirit of this graphic vision in her famous lines: “Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord; He is trampling out the vintage where the grapes of wrath are stored; He has loosed the fateful lightning of His terrible swift sword; His truth is marching on.” IVP New Testament Commentary Series

[24] Expositor's Bible Commentary (Abridged Edition): New Testament

[25] This would correlate with the Horsemen as being primarily (though not only) about what Christians will experience in terms of persecution.

[26] There is an ironic parallel between Christ (through his angels) treading the bloody winepress of God's wrath here, and Christ enduring God's wrath against sin on the cross by shedding his own blood. The further irony that both this judgment and the judgment of sin at Jesus' crucifixion took place outside the city (see Hebrews 13:12 and perhaps Mt 21:39) may well be intentional. IVP New Testament Commentary Series

[27] Matthew 26:52

[28] Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary of the New Testament

[29] Joel located this final judgment in the valley of Jehoshaphat (Joel 3:2), or Hinnom, which lies south of Jerusalem. This was the traditional valley of judgment in the Old Testament (Jer. 7:31–32; 19:5–6) that was the model for Gehenna seen in Jewish intertestamental literature (cf. 2 Esdras 7:36) and the New Testament (Matt. 5:22). Later traditions believed it to be the valley as the Kidron, east of Jerusalem. John places the location outside of the city of Babylon: basically, outside of the secular city in a broader sense. Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary of the New Testament

[30] Yet the remark that the vintage was trodden outside the city may remind us of one who absorbed in His own person the judgment due to mankind, and did so outside the city (cf. Jn 19:20; Heb. 13:12)Zondervan Bible Commentary (One Volume)

[31] “Revelation does not contain two competing Christologies and theologies—one of power and one of weakness—symbolized by the Lion and the Lamb, respectively. Revelation presents Christ as the Lion who reigns as the Lamb, not in spite of being the Lamb. This means also that Revelation presents God as the one who reigns through the Lamb, not in spite of the Lamb. All of this means that judgment by God/Christ in Revelation must be an expression of divine identity that is not in conflict with Lamb power. The judgment of the world originates in its failure to believe and be faithful to this God. When it creates its own deities, it suffers the natural consequences of deifying the non-divine. In this sense, judgment proceeds from the throne of God and from the Lamb (6:16–17) because the rejection of the divine gift of life carries with it inherent deadly consequences…when humans reject Lamb power they experience it as imperial disaster—disordered desire, death, and destruction. The first tidal wave of violent imagery expresses the apocalyptic insight that the world’s suffering is allowed by God, but is more fundamentally a result of sin. We would of course be misguided not to see these also as divine punishment, similar to the snowball effect of sin unleashed in the world according to Paul in Rom 1:18—32. The question “human sin or divine punishment?” presupposes a false dichotomy and asks for an unnecessary choice; the answer is of course, “both.” (From Reading Revelation Responsibly)

[32] Pulpit Commentary, https://biblehub.com/commentaries/revelation/14-11.htm. Check out C.S. Lewis’s book The Great Divorce for a novelized version of this idea.

[33] We may sow the wind, but who can stand the whirlwind? See Hosea 8:7

[34] “Sometimes, God’s judgment in Revelation takes the form of imperial practices themselves, or the consequences of such practices. War, famine, pestilence, death, injustice in the marketplace, and rebellion are all…human evils rather than cosmic events… We would be misguided not to see these also as divine punishment, similar to the snowball effect of sin unleashed in the world according to Paul in Rom 1:18-32. The question “human sin or divine punishment?” presupposes a false dichotomy and asks for an unnecessary choice; the answer is of course, ‘both.’” Michael Gorman, Reading Revelation Responsibly

[35] NRSV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible

[36] Smoke shows up everywhere: there are constantly smoky things rising to God. 

·      Smoke means the glory (greatness) of God (Revelation 15:8).

·      The smoke of the incense purified the prayers of the saints, ((Revelation 8:4)

·      A symbol of destruction (Revelation 9)

·      A sign of spiritual pollution (Revelation 9)

[37]  “The heads of the horses looked like lions’ heads, and fire, smoke, and sulfur came out of their mouths. A third of humanity was killed by these three plagues, that is, by the fire, the smoke, and the sulfur that came out of their mouths.” (Revelation 8) 

[38] Zondervan Bible Commentary (One Volume)

[39] In the context of Edom, ‘forever’ either means ‘people will never forget this’ or ‘it stretched so high into the sky it looked like it went on forever.” Or both. 

[40] IVP New Testament Commentary Series

[41] Revelation (Beale)

[42] HELPS Word-studies: 372 anápausis – inner rest (tranquility). “Rest, cessation from labor, refreshment.” 

[43] Ibid

[44] HELPS Word-studies 373  completing a process…" properly, to give (experience) rest after the needed task is completed; to pause (rest) "after precious toil and care."

[45] Ibid

[46] HT C.S. Lewis for that phrase

7 Trumpets (Revelation 8-11)

 Now when the Lamb opened the seventh seal there was silence in heaven for about half an hour[1].  Then I saw the seven angels who stand before God, and seven trumpets were given to them. Another angel holding a golden censer came and was stationed at the altar. A large amount of incense was given to him to offer up, with the prayers of all the saints, on the golden altar that is before the throne.  

 The Old Testament associates silence with divine judgment.[2] This seems to be a response to the death of and the prayers of saints that bring about the judgment on those through whom evil and suffering have been unleashed in the world. 

The smoke coming from the incense, along with the prayers of the saints, ascended before God from the angel’s hand. Then the angel took the censer, filled it with fire from the altar, and threw it on the earth[3], and there were crashes of thunder, roaring, flashes of lightning, and an earthquake.[4]

The prayers go up; fire, a common biblical metaphor for a judgment that either refines or destroys, comes down. Now, the trumpets show how God’s judgment of evil impacts the earth as we groan our way toward the end.   

 Now the seven angels[5] holding the seven trumpets prepared to blow them.[6]

Remember we talked about the "birth pangs" Jesus warned would start in the generation of his listeners? The birthing process is a lot of pain, a lot of unpleasantness, but a good result at the end. There will be life on the other side, but the process is going to be hard. 

We are going to see the removal of peace; the destruction of the things that prop up the idolatry and empires of the world; deprivation; suffering; loss; despair.  This is reaping what was sown.  Consumer cultures consume themselves. Violent cultures ruin themselves. Indulgent cultures soften themselves. God sends the whirlwind. 

[Babylon’s] sins are piled up to heaven, and God has remembered her crimes. Give back to her as she has given; pay her back double for what she has done. Pour her a double portion from her own cup... God has judged her with the judgment she imposed on you.” (Revelation 18:5-6; 20)”[7]

A third will be impacted,[8] meaning it’s not total judgment. There is time for people to see what is going on and repent. In that sense, while this judgment is certainly about retribution for the evil done, it also holds the potential to be rehabilitative and restorative. It’s a good reminder of how to pray for justice/judgment: may it not only stop the evil, but may it be the means by which the evildoers come to their senses.

The images are apocalyptic: flaming mountains that are nations; stars that are angels; a speaking eagle. I think we are meant to see “through” them, weighing them like we do numbers.[9] There is room for the famine to be deprivations of all kinds, or the bitterness of the water to be a contrast to “the living water,” which speaks to spiritual realities. We are going to see everything shake. The people have placed their trust in idols, in false gods, in what is unstable and chaotic, and it’s not going to end well.[10] 

 The first angel[11] blew his trumpet, and there was hail and fire mixed with blood, and it was thrown at the earth so that a third of the earth (soil) was burned up, a third of the trees were burned up, and all the green grass was burned up.

The fire and blood are symbols of the wrath of God.[12] They can’t be literal: the blood and hail would put out the fire; a fire that destroyed 1/3 of the dirt and trees and all the grass would destroy the globe.

The first 4 trumpets are modeled after the plagues on Egypt (Exodus 7-11). Revelation 15:3 compares the return of Jesus to the first exodus;[13] it would make sense that the second exodus is ushered in in similar fashion.[14]  

Since the plagues of Egypt directly challenged the gods of the Egyptians, I am inclined to see this trumpet as a spiritual warfare broadside against the gods of this world, judging the world systems behind the evil and corruption of the world (which we will say more about at the 7th trumpet).[15]However, just like the first Exodus, it’s not too late repent and join those about to head to the Promised Land.[16]   

 Then the second angel blew his trumpet, and something like a great mountain of burning fire was thrown into the sea.[17]A third[18] of the sea became blood, and a third of the creatures living in the sea died, and a third of the ships were completely destroyed.

In the Bible, mountains often stand in for kingdoms[19] or nations, many subject to God's judgment.[20] Jeremiah speaks of Babylon as a destroying mountain which would be burned by fire (Jeremiah 51:25) that will sink into the waters never to rise again.[21] We will see this again with the destruction of Babylon’s global maritime commerce in chapter 18.[22] Rome depended on the sea for food and commerce; the sea captains lament Babylon’s ruin.[23]

Once again, see ‘through’ this: it’s an indictment on nation(s) plural. All nations. God’s judgment will rock the gods of this world, and then hit the issue most talked about in the Bible: money, the idol of wealth, commerce, power and security. Look how rocked we have been by the shipping issues in the last few months (“We can’t have Christmas!”). There is nothing new under the sun.  

Then the third angel blew his trumpet, and a huge star burning like a torch fell from the sky; it landed on a third of the rivers and on the springs of water. (Now the name of the star is Wormwood.) So a third of the waters became wormwood, and many people died from these waters because they were poisoned.

In Jewish apocalypses, stars sometimes appeared like burning mountains; one fell into the sea and burned both the sea and Israel’s oppressors.[24]  1 Enoch 18:13 and 21:3[25] describes the preliminary judgment of the fallen angels as “stars like great burning mountains.”[26] Stars represent angelic beings in Revelation (see on 1:19). OT angels often represent earthly peoples and kingdoms.

In fact, the rabbis interpreted the Exodus 7:16–18 plague on the waters as a judgment on the Nile god, who represented the people. They would quote Isaiah 24:21 - “the Lord will punish the host of heaven on high and the kings of the earth on earth.” Here Babylon’s ‘angel’ appears to be judged along with the nation. It was prophesied. Not only are the nations shaken, but any spiritual powers behind them have been toppled from their place of authority as well. 

O shining one, son of the dawn! You have been cut down to the ground, O conqueror of the nations…  But you were brought down to Sheol, to the remote slopes of the Pit. (Isaiah 14:12-15) 

Wormwood recalls the bitter water at Marah - still on an Exodus theme (Exodus 15:23). If the “living waters” of chapters 7 and 21 represent the reward of eternal, spiritual life for faithfulness through suffering (7:17; 21:6; 22:1), then the waters of death in Chapter 8 represent a punishment of suffering associated with eternal, spiritual death. 

Then the fourth angel blew his trumpet, and a third of the sun was struck, and a third of the moon, and a third of the stars, so that a third of them were darkened.[27] And there was no light for a third of the day and for a third of the night likewise.[28] 

Our earth is too finely tuned to not be destroyed by literal celestial events like that. It’s a known image of judgment to John’s audience: at God’s judgment of Edom, “all the starry host will fall” (Isaiah 34:4).  The Dictionary Of Bible Themes notes the many ways in which celestial bodies played multiple roles in the Bible, but here’s what’s relevant to us today. Under the category of “Worship of the Stars,” we find: 

·      Prohibited by God Deuteronomy 4:19; 17:3 2 Kings 23:4-5

·      Judgment of star worshippers Jer 8:2: 19:12-13; Amos 5:25-27; Acts 7:42-43

·      Examples of star worship 2 Ki 17:16; 2 Ki 21:3-5; 2 Chronicles 33:5; Acts 28:11

·      Idolatrous worship of the moon Deut. 4:19; 17:3; 2 Ki 23:5; Job 31:26

·      Sun Worship Forbidden to God’s people Deut 4:19;17:2-5; Job 31:26-28

·      Practiced in Israel and Egypt Ez 8:16; 2 Ki 23:5,11; Jer 8:1-2; 43:13

 Judaism has long interpreted The Exodus plague of darkness as a spiritual, cultural, or mental darkness. It's the darkness of despair when people realize the futility of their idolatry and the disaster that is coming up on them (Jeremiah 15:19, Amos 8:9, Joel 2).[29] 

 Then I looked, and I heard an eagle flying directly overhead[30], proclaiming with a loud voice, “Woe! Woe! Woe[31]to the earth dwellers because of the remaining sounds of the trumpets of the three angels who are about to blow them!”

 God’s people are spared the following plagues, as happened with the later Egyptian plagues.[32]Since God’s people are spared, this is good reason to think that what follows has to do with spiritual judgment that will ‘pass over’ God’s faithful people sealed by the Lamb’s blood.   

Then the fifth angel blew his trumpet, and I saw a star that had fallen from the sky to the earth, and he was given the key to the shaft of the abyss. He opened the shaft of the abyss and smoke rose out of it like smoke from a giant furnace[33]. The sun and the air were darkened with smoke from the shaft.  Then out of the smoke came locusts onto the earth, and they were given power like that of the scorpions of the earth.[34] 

The “star” that John sees is an angel (20:1) with the key (3:7) to open the Abyss. The Abyss was believed by John’s audience to be the underworld prison of evil spirits.[35] 

 They were told not to damage the grass of the earth, or any green plant or tree,[36] but only those people who did not have the seal of God on their forehead. The locusts were not given permission to kill them, but only to torment them for five months, and their torture was like that of a scorpion when it stings a person. In those days people will seek death, but will not be able to find it; they will long to die, but death will flee from them. Now the locusts[37] looked like horses equipped for battle.[38] On their heads were something like crowns similar to gold, and their faces looked like men’s faces.  They had hair like women’s hair, and their teeth were like lions’ teeth. They had breastplates like iron breastplates, and the sound of their wings was like the noise of many horse-drawn chariots charging into battle. They have tails and stingers like scorpions, and their ability to injure people for five months is in their tails. They have as king over them the angel of the abyss, whose name in Hebrew is Abaddon, and in Greek, Apollyon.

Notice that the locusts don't do what no locusts normally do. They can't touch any green thing - or those who have the Seal of God upon their forehead. One assumes the threat is non-physical: for example, the devastation and famine of the soul (Amos 8:11-14).[39]  I favor the view that this describes demonic activity on earth.  

• “Now the Spirit expressly says that in latter times some will depart from the faith, giving heed to deceiving spirits and doctrines of demons…” (1 Timothy 4:1). 

•  “‘Fallen! Fallen is Babylon the Great!’ She has become a dwelling for demons and a haunt for every impure spirit.” (Revelation 18:2)

• “The horses are men, and the riders are evil spirits.” (Primasius and Andrew of Caesarea, 500s)

• “A terrifying picture of demonic oppression.” (Orthodox Study Bible)

• “These locusts probably represent demons.” (Believer’s Bible Commentary)

• Demonic forces out of the abyss… [John uses] frogs to represent demonic powers in the recapitulation in Revelation 16:13. (Expositor’s Bible Commentary: New Testament)

 This aligns with Christianity’s view of an active supernatural world that tries to influence, oppress, and even seek to take control of humanity to bend them away from God. John’s view of this is sobering. It sounds like he is showing a practical application of what Paul wrote: when you offer yourself as a slave, you are a slave of the one you obey. (Romans 6:16)

 The first woe has passed, but two woes are still coming after these things! Then the sixth angel blew his trumpet, and I heard a single voice coming from the horns on the golden altar that is before God, saying to the sixth angel, the one holding the trumpet, “Set free the four angels who are bound at the great river Euphrates!” Then the four angels[40] who had been prepared for this hour, day, month, and year were set free to kill a third of humanity. The number of soldiers on horseback was 200,000,000; I heard their number.

The Euphrates was the boundary behind which enemies lurked. [41] It’s a physical image for a spiritual reality. The numerical background for this huge number is Daniel 7:10. It just means there’s a lot. A lot a lot.

 Now this is what the horses and their riders looked like in my vision: The riders had breastplates that were fiery red, dark blue, and sulfurous yellow in color. The heads of the horses looked like lions’ heads, and fire, smoke, and sulfur came out of their mouths. A third of humanity was killed by these three plagues, that is, by the fire, the smoke, and the sulfur that came out of their mouths. For the power of the horses resides in their mouths and in their tails, because their tails are like snakes/scorpions[42], having heads that inflict injuries. 

This invasion is often compared to the daunting Parthian army. See ‘through’ it. You think they are scary? The spiritual battle is worse.  

The rest of humanity, who had not been killed by these plagues, did not repent of the works of their hands, so that they did not stop worshiping demons and idols made of gold, silver, bronze, stone, and wood—idols that cannot see or hear or walk about. Furthermore, they did not repent of their murders, of their magic spells, of their sexual immorality, or of their stealing.

INTERLUDE

An angel measures the temple, John eats a scroll that tastes good going down (this story ends well!) and then does not sit well at all (#birthpangs). Then two witnesses show up in a city for 3 ½ years, breathe fire on anyone who challenges them, get killed, then come back to life. 

MEASURING THE TEMPLE

Measuring the temple is best understood against the background of Ezekiel 40 – 48 in which measuring is associated with establishment and protection. Measuring suggests God's presence, which is guaranteed to be with the temple community living on Earth before the Lord's return.[43] But the angel didn’t measure the outer court of the temple. Short version: your soul will be safe, even if your skin is not.

THE TWO WITNESSES

• 2 lampstands, which are identified as churches in chapters 1 & 2,[44] have the powers of both Moses (law) and Elijah (prophet) and establish the truthfulness of the gospel message. (Numbers 35:30; Deuteronomy 17:6; Matthew 18:16, Luke 10:1-24). 

• The three and a half years (Daniel’s “time, times, and half a time”) is from Christ's resurrection until His final coming.[45]

• The fire is God's judgment on the world’s sin through the spoken word of Scripture.[46] In Luke 9, the disciples wanted to copy Elijah by calling down fire upon some Samaritan villagers. Jesus rebuked them, but then sent out groups (of two) to declare the danger of judgment (and the good news of mercy) through the proclamation of the Gospel. 

• The great city where the bodies lie is the world: Rome is Sodom, Egypt, Babylon. It’s all the troublesome nations that have plagued God’s people in different ways. 

• The restoration to life is taken directly from the “dry bones” resurrection of Ezekiel 37:5 -10.[47] God’s church will not stay down.

• The people repent – or at least acknowledge the power of God, which might not be the same thing…[48]

The Seal Interlude: “You are sealed. Endure.” 

The Trumpet Interlude: “You are secure. Witness.” 

Then the seventh angel blew his trumpet, and there were loud voices in heaven saying: “The kingdom of the world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of his Christ, and he will reign for ever and ever.” Then the twenty-four elders who are seated on their thrones before God threw themselves down with their faces to the ground and worshiped God  with these words: “We give you thanks, Lord God, the All-Powerful, the one who is and who was[49], because you have taken your great power and begun to reign. The nations were enraged, but your wrath has come, and the time has come for the dead to be judged, and the time has come to give to your servants, the prophets, their reward, as well as to the saints and to those who revere your name, both small and great, and the time has come to destroy[50] those who destroy the earth.” Then the temple of God in heaven was opened and the ark of his covenant was visible within his temple.[51] And there were flashes of lightning, roaring, crashes of thunder, an earthquake, and a great hailstorm.

 This is still a “woe,” because the ‘woes’ are from the perspective of the world.  God’s reign means evil’s judgment. It’s not good news for everybody. 

However, The picture of God’s judgment here in Revelation shows a God who has been restraining the full, devastating consequence of the sin we have sown. It also shows a God who, when “our iniquities are full,” will no longer hold back the chaos from the abyss. He will give us the full experience of our masters. 

If paradise is being fully in the presence of the one we serve with all the blessings that follow, perhaps hell may be thought of as fully experiencing the presence of the one we have been serving (the dragon and his servants) with all its cursings.

Meanwhile, God sends warnings. There are not only little oasis or outposts of heaven that function as signposts for eternity with the Lamb; we find the same kind of signposts for an eternity with the Dragon. 

·      What we think will never fail, fails.

·      What we think will always provides, stops providing.

·      What once measured our success begins to measure our failure. 

·      What we thought filled us was actually consuming us.

·      What we thought was refreshing us becomes bitter and sickening.

·      What we thought brought flourishing brought destruction.

·      What we thought made life matter made life meaningless.

No matter who you think the witnesses are, their purpose is clear: with holiness, grace, and hope, faithfully preach and model the message of the Slain Lamb to all inside and outside church walls so that as many as possible may be delivered from the judgment to come. 

The witnesses are never promised a time of prosperity of wealth or independence or popularity or even freedom to practice our faith. What they are promised is that God’s grace will be sufficient (2 Corinthians 12:9), and that the true church will rise from the ashes.

No matter what happens, I know this: We are called to be faithful witnesses to God in a sin-captured world.[52] Yes, this is daunting, but if you are committed Jesus, you are sealed. You have been claimed. 

For the true church, Revelation is sobering but also exciting: the cost may be high, but the end will be glorious. Revelation is supposed to bring hope. The king is returning. Evil will be undone. God’s originally good Earth will be renewed. Bear holy and faithful witness to it. [53]

___________________________________________________________________________

[1] Don’t sweat the time frame. It’s just a literary device that means it happened :)

[2] Habakkuk 2:20 -3:15; Zechariah 2:13 -3:2; Zephaniah 1:8 7-18

[3] “The smoke of the incense…shows that the petition of chapter 6:9 -10 is now being presented before God. Their petition for judgment has been found acceptable.” (Beale)

[4] “Peals of thunder, flashes of lightning and an earthquake” is almost identical to the description of the last judgment in 11:19 and 16:18 as well as 4:5. (Beale) 

[5] Jewish tradition identifies seven angels who offer up the prayers of the saints as they enter before the glory of the Holy One (Tobit 12:15). (Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary Of The New Testament)

[6] “The primary perspective of the first five seals was on the trials to which believers must pass; now, the focus in the first six trumpet are on the judgment which unbelievers both inside and outside the church must endure.” (Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary)  “In the first round, we were looking at the tribulation through the lens of the church. In round two, we see it from the vantage point of the world.” (Mark Moore, How To Dodge A Dragon: An Uncommentary On Revelation) 

[7] “Sometimes, God’s judgment in Revelation takes the form of imperial practices themselves, or the consequences of such practices. War, famine, pestilence, death, injustice in the marketplace, and rebellion are all…human evils rather than cosmic events… We would  be misguided not to see these also as divine punishment, similar to the snowball effect of sin unleashed in the world according to Paul in Rom 1:18-32. The question “human sin or divine punishment?” presupposes a false dichotomy and asks for an unnecessary choice; the answer is of course, ‘both’”. Michael Gorman, Reading Revelation Responsibly

[8] “Third part is a rabbinism, expressing a considerable number. "When Rabbi Akiba prayed, wept, rent his garments, put of his shoes, and sat in the dust, the world was struck with a curse; and then the third part of the olives, the third part of the wheat, and the third part of the barley, was smitten.” (Adam Clarke)

[9] “Cosmic signs [are]symbols of the distress and disease generated by human evil. [This is] indirect divine judgment.” Michael Gorman, Reading Revelation Responsibly

[10] Greg Beale notes that while we are told serious things about the ‘world’ collapsing under God’s judgment, physical symbols are meant to point us toward spiritual realities.

[11] Heisser points to Moyise’s Old Testament in Revelation to note the trumpet judgments in Revelation 8, 9, and a bit of 10 follow the themes of Joel 2-3 and Amos 1-2.

[12] Tyconius (370), Oecumenius (500s), Andrew of Caeserea (563) thought it might come through warfare. “The land was wasted; the trees-the chiefs of the nation, were destroyed; and the grass-the common people, slain, or carried into captivity.” (Adam Clarke)

[13] The redeemed sing the song of Moses and of the Lamb

[14] From Mark Moore, How To Dodge A Dragon: An Uncommentary On Revelation:

 Israelites in Egypt - Christians in Asia Minor/All of us   The people of God suffer oppression; God sends plagues to demonstrate his power/provoke repentance; repentance does not follow; God defeats the oppressor; God’s people praise the God who will reign forever; the ark of the covenant is present with God’s people

[15]  Michael Heisser notes, “Where do we get the nations and their gods to begin with? Genesis 11. Babylon.” And that’s the mountain that is about to be thrown into the sea…. 

[16] When Israel left Egypt, “a mixed multitude went up with them.” (Exodus 12:38) 

[17] “Mountain, in prophetic language, signifies a kingdom; Jeremiah 51:25; Jeremiah 51:27; Jeremiah 51:30; Jeremiah 51:58. Great disorders… are represented by mountains being cast into the midst of the sea, Psalms 46:2. Seas and collections of waters mean peoples, as is shown in this book, Revelation 17:15. “(Adam Clarke) 

[18] A fourth of the earth was affected by the seal judgments; a third is now devastated by the trumpet judgments. There is a progression in intensity.

[19] Revelation14:1; 17:9; 21:10

[20] Isaiah 41:15, 42:15; Ezekiel 35; Zechariah 4:7

[21] Babylon’s judgment is as a stone thrown into the sea in Revelation 18:21 

[22] Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary

[23] “Every shipmaster and all who sail anywhere and every sailor and as many as work on the sea... cried out when they saw the smoke of her burning... and they were weeping and mourning, saying ‘woe, woe, is the great city, through which all those who have ships in the sea became wealthy because of her wealth.’ ” (18:17–19) 

[24] NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible

[25] Revered Jewish literature from around 200 BC. While not Scripture, it functioned as a commentary that was highly influential in shaping Jewish thought. 

[26] Heisser, from an episode on the Naked Bible podcast

[27] Parallel to Exodus 10:21–23.

[28] Early church fathers were inclined to see the celestial bodies as the church, and the darkness as the result of heretics dimming the light of Scripture.

[29] Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary

[30] This eagle is in the “middle heaven,” the home of the sun, moon, planets, and stars (Revelation 14:6; 19:17).  It’s a place where all the world will see/hear.

[31] “Look! An eagle is swooping down, spreading its wings over Moab ... Woe to you, O Moab! The people of Chemosh are destroyed.” (Jeremiah 48:40, 46).

[32] How do they do this? “‘Come out of her, my people, so that you will not share in her sins, so that you will not receive any of her plagues.” (Revelation 18:4)

[33] The abyss in the Old Testament represents chaos. Here, the abyss seems to represent part of the spiritual world that is the home of evil that will be judged. That’s why it can be referred to as watery (chaos) and also fiery (judgment). 

[34] Many of the early church fathers were convinced this was about heretics, though a few chalked it up to demons… that were inspiring heretics. (All my notes on Early Church Fathers come from Ancient Christian Commentary On Scripture.)

[35] Demons pleaded with Jesus to spare them the Abyss. (Luke 8:30–31)

[36] Once again a reminder this is imagery, as all the grass was already gone.

[37] Like horses prepared for battle: a conquering host. Gold-like crowns: authorized to rule in people’s lives. Human-appearing faces: creatures of intelligence. Hair like women’s: hair was considered seductive. Lion-like teeth: ferocious and cruel. Armor-like iron breastplates: difficult to attack and destroy, etc. (Believer’s Bible Commentary)

[38] OT imagery. “They have the appearance of horses; they gallop along like cavalry” (Joel 2:4). An army of locusts “has the teeth of a lion” (Joel 1:6) and make a noise “like that of chariots” (2:5). Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary of the New Testament

[39] Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary

[40] This seems to be a recapitulation of the 4 Horsemen.

[41] Heisser notes that beyond the Euphrates was the domain of Baal. The language of the Old Testament relates not just to the invading armies that Israel had to put up with, but also the idea that there are cosmic powers itching to invade.

[42] Jewish tradition held that in Sheol and Abaddon there were “angels of destruction,” who were in authority over thousands of scorpions (Heisser). Scorpions and serpents were associated in Old Testament and extra-biblical Jewish writings as metaphorical images for false teaching. (Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary)

[43] Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary

[44] Only two of the seven churches/lampstands remained faithful in Revelation 2-3: Smyrna and Philadelphia. Perhaps these two churches represent the faithful church. The whole world will see the two witnesses, which is understandable if they're a global church. That the witnesses are called trees comes from the vision of Zechariah in chapter 4. 

[45] Funny but true story: the Babylonian kings tried to predict what Daniel prophesied by doing the math of the 70 weeks. When nothing would happen in a literal 70 weeks, they would recount and try again…because the numbers were meant to be weighed, not counted.

[46] “I and making my words in your mouth fire and this people wood, and it will consume them.” (Jeremiah 5:14).  

[47] Greg Beale, Revelation: A Shorter Commentary

[48] Compare to Egypt: “And the Egyptians will know that I am Yehovah when I stretch out my hand against Egypt and bring the Israelites out of it.” They knew and acknowledged, but that’s not the same as salvation.

[49] Ooh. No more “and is to come.” He has arrived! 

[50] Here’s another reason I tend to see most of God’s judgment in Revelation as God giving people over to themselves. The word here for ‘destroy’ is the same word ‘destroy’ at the end of the verse that they did to the earth! “’Diaphtheírō (from diá, ‘thoroughly,’ which intensifies phtheírō, ‘defile, corrupt) properly, thoroughly corrupt, totally degenerate (disintegrate); waste away by the decaying influence of moral (spiritual) impurity; ‘utterly corrupt’; becoming thoroughly disabled (morally depraved), ‘all the way through’ (‘utterly decayed’).” #windandwhirlwind (HELPS Word Studies)

[51] In the Old Testament, the ark was a sign of God’s presence. It was usually behind a veil, but here it is fully revealed and accessible to all. 

[52] Thanks to http://newlisbon.church/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Revelation-Workbook.pdf for some really helpful insights.

[53] How do we do this? Faith/trust/belief based on the person and work of Jesus; commitment that orients/prioritizes our life; lifestyle committed to holiness (set apart for God); words that speak truth righteously; consistent, conscientious witness.

EPHESUS, Part One: On Beasts And Babylon (Revelation 2:1-7)

[1] We are told to obey the prophecy of Revelation (1:3) – and how do you obey a prophecy? Well, prophecy in the Bible is usually (like, 85% of the time) a revelation of who God is, what God desires, and what God demands of us rather than a discussion of the future. So think of Revelation primarily (though not exclusively) as a handbook for Christian living in challenging times, with an ending to human history in which the supremacy of Christ is made clear.[2] Revelation is meant to strengthen our faith that God is with us now in our trials, and that He will one day end the groaning of a sin-soaked world and usher in a New Heaven and a New Earth. 

I think we typically focus on the apocalyptic stuff in Revelation when we think of the book, but that’s not how it starts. It starts with personal letters to churches acknowledging their hardship, commending or correcting them as needed, and pointing them toward the goodness of what God offers them in His Kingdom. Then John gives an artist’s illustration of all the dynamics referenced in the letter. 

If you have seen or read A Monster Calls or I Kill Giants,[3] you know how this works. They are stories about grief. Part of the movie is ‘real world’ conflict, but the story quickly bumps into an imaginative fantasy world with giants and monsters in which the same story unfolds in a way that captures our imaginations along with our hearts. 

So we are going to move through the letters, but I will try to bring in the artist’s illustrations as we go along.

THE 7 LETTERS

1:19 “Write, therefore, what you have seen, what is now and what will take place later. 20 The mystery[4] of the seven stars that you saw in my right hand and of the seven golden lampstands is this: The seven stars are the angels[5] of the seven churches, and the seven lampstands are the seven churches.”

 The letters address 7 congregations in Asia Minor in the order a messenger taking a circuitous route would have traveled. There were surely more churches: weigh the number 7, the number of completion. It’s a message for all churches. There is a pattern in the letters: 

• the 1st and 7th – the bookends – are struggling with a lukewarmness that comes from a lack of passion for Christ and His Kingdom. For the 7th, God has nothing good to say.

•  The 2nd and 6th – the poor, the suffering, the powerless - are doing well spiritually. 

• The middle three are once again in trouble. 

 If these 7 churches represent the ‘church’ at the time (#weighthenumbers) and stand in for churches that are and will be, then we are more likely to be in a church that is struggling with spiritual compromise rather than flourishing in an unadulterated splendor. 

I don’t say this to discourage us. It’s just to point out that we have to be willing to do self-assessment and repent as needed. Odds are good that this needs to be the rhythm or our personal and corporate life, especially if we live in circumstances where we are comfortable.[6] Poverty and persecution do not guarantee holiness, but if this overview of churches is meant to reveal something important to us, it would suggest that cultural hardship has ability to refine the church in ways that cultural comfort does not. 

EPHESUS

Inscriptions record that Ephesus was one of the greatest cities of Asia with libraries, gymnasiums, and ornate administrative buildings. The city was a favorite with tourists of the time.[7] Ephesus was a major center for the worship of Roma, the spiritual embodiment of the Empire. It’s famous temple for Artemis was one of the Seven Wonders of the World.[8] This temple worship meant a lot of prostitutes since Artemis was the goddess of fertility. The economy was dependent on trade associated with trade guilds centered around temple worship.[9] So, Ephesus: beautiful, wealthy, exciting, full of alluring pleasures, the height of what Roman culture had to offer. 

2 The One: Write down My words, and send them to the messenger (angel) [10] of the church in Ephesus. [11]“These are the words of the One who holds the seven stars in His right hand[12], the One who walks and moves among the golden lampstands [13]:

This is to the church in Ephesus. Any interpretation of the book of Revelation needs to have made sense to the readers in those seven churches. We can and do benefit from what these churches were told because this is a Revelation of what was and what is to come, but the revelation was to them first, and it didn’t do them any good if they didn’t understand it :)

“I know your deeds, your tireless labor, and your patient endurance. I know you do not tolerate those who do evil. Furthermore, you have diligently tested those who claim to be apostles, and you have found that they are not true witnesses. You have correctly found them to be false.[14]  I know you are patiently enduring and holding firm on behalf of My name. You have not become faint.

 Okay, kudos to the Christians in Ephesus! They are enduring in the face of the hardships that come with being a Christian in Ephesus. That could be anything from resisting temptation, to paying the social and economic price of not worshipping in the cults of the empire, to physical persecution. They are also guarding the truths of the faith, and they are nailing it. These are big deals. Who wouldn’t want this on their resume?  

“However, I have this against you: you have abandoned your first love[15] [for Christ and others[16]]. Do you remember what it was like before you fell? It’s time to rethink and change your ways; go back to the deeds you did at first. However, if you do not return, I will come quickly and personally remove your lampstand from its place[17].

In Matthew, Jesus had predicted that "many false prophets will appear and deceive many people" and that "the love of most will grow cold" (Mt 24:11-12). Ephesus passed the first test but not the second. (More on abandoning and returning to our first love next week.)

But you do have this to your credit: you despise[18] the deeds of the Nicolaitans and how they concede to evil. I also hate what they do. 

Here’s what we know about the Nicolaitans. They taught that spiritual liberty gave them…well, liberty to pretty much do what they wanted: have multiple wives, do what they wanted sexually, eat meat offered to idols (probably as part of being in a trade guild). They even mixed pagan temple rituals with the Christian ceremonies. In the letter to Pergamum, this type of compromise will be called the teaching of Balaam (vv. 14–15); at Thyatira, it’s followers of Jezebel (v. 20).[19] 

* * * * *

In this first letter, we already see hints of two things that will be themes in Revelation.   

 First, Christians will be tempted to fall away because of hardship. Being true to the faith invited exclusion, expulsion, and even persecution by the Romans.[20] Following Jesus was costing them social standing, access to society, the ability to make a good living, and even personal safety. This letter will end with a reminder that some will be faithful “even unto death.” 

Second, Christians will be tempted to give in to the allure of sinful pleasures offered by the Empire. 

They are going to be intimidated by power and tempted by pleasure. This has been how empires have challenged the people of God for 2,000 years. That’s the text. Here comes the illustration. 

• Revelation 13 will introduce Satan as a dragon (a huge serpent, a snake; imagery beginning in Genesis). Satan is behind the forces of evil in the world. Satan motivates attacks on the church.

• A scarlet beast[21] comes out of ocean in Revelation 14; people will worship the dragon and then the beast: “Who is like the beast? Who can wage war against it?” Pretty sure that’s Rome for the early church, the indomitable power at the time. More broadly, think of earthly empires in general. They were, are, and will be beastly.

•  A second beast (“false prophet” in Chapter 16) then emerges that will get people to worship the first beast. By worship, think allegiance. The empire becomes a source of hope; the empire dictates priorities; the empire establishes what the good life is and how it ought to be lived. This second beast “gives breath” to the Empire: it’s the propaganda machine (media, entertainment, education, politicians, industry heads, civic organizations… anything that promotes the agenda of the Empire.) It has horns like a lamb (leaders who look good to followers of Jesus) but speaks like a dragon. There are parts of the beast that remind people of a lamb. That’s the imagery used to describe Jesus just a couple verses earlier in Revelation 13. There’s at least a part of the false prophet/second beast that will look like home to Christians. It will be easy to compromise: “Yeah, but…look at those lamb-like horns!! I know, I know, it says dragony things, but…look at those little horns!” 

• To make things worse, Babylon rides into the story. The children of Israel were not invited or tempted to become Egyptians when they were enslaved. It was an easy empire to resist. But Babylon offered acceptance, wealth and even power when they were exiled. That was compelling, and thus dangerous. The most effective empire is one that seduces you. The spiritual survival of the early Christians depended on their ability to see Rome as a doomed Babylon (Revelation 19). So the Babylon side of Rome is portrayed as an alluring prostitute, sitting on the beast. She’s drunk with the blood of God’s people – in other words, she has consumed a lot of them. And though the language of prostitution makes us think about sex (and temple worship surely included that), Old Testament imagery of spiritual adultery was always spiritual adultery – that is, idolatry. And John makes clear that Babylon is all about the idol of wealth and power.[22]

How does a beast conquer? Through power and coercion. Even if it looks good at first, it always makes the turn.  How does a prostitute conquer? Through seduction. What two dangers face the Christians in Ephesus and everywhere? Compromising their faith from fear of the empire’s power or love of the empire’s pleasure.  

So let’s talk about Rome (the First Beast) and Domitian (the Second Beast/False Prophet who serves the empire and furthers its agenda). It’s 1st century specific, but Revelation is about what was andwhat is and what is to come. I think the “what was” included previous emperors, with Nero as the violent supervillain. “What is” is Domitian. Fill in as needed with all empires and leaders as history unfolds.  

• Domitian put in place economic, military, and cultural programs to restore the Empire’s splendor. And it was splendid in many ways.[23]

• He bumped the value of Roman currency to new levels.

• He spent lavishly on the reconstruction of Rome. 

• He spent a TON of money on congiaria (vessels filled with wine, grain or money) #bribes

• He revived the practice of public banquets. 

That’s how Babylon (with its love/idolatry of money, luxury and comfort) rides in on the back of the Beast. Now, the horns like a lamb. 

• After nominating himself to the office that supervised Roman morals, Domitian made adultery punishable by exile. When the Vestal Virgins were found to have broken their sacred vows of chastity, they were buried alive.

• Domitian punished people who made eunuchs. 

• Libel and slander became punishable by exile or death.

• He prosecuted corruption among public officials and removed jurors if they accepted bribes.

• He didn’t favor family members for public office. 

• Other religions were tolerated if they didn’t interfere with public order or could assimilate with Roman religions. Jews were heavily taxed, but history records no executions of Jewish worshipers based on religious offenses.

• A lot of the time, Christians were able to avoid physical persecution.[24] Provincial authorities did so occasionally under Domitian, but it was nothing like what Nero did. Most believers suffered more from the stigma of society rather than government harassment. Revelation actually names only one person from seven churches who had been killed. If they could just be ‘good enough citizens’ they might avoid being hurt, and they might even become comfortable.

 When the first century believers looked at Rome under Domitian’s reign, it was easier than it had been in a while to see an alluring goddess - Roma, Babylon -  who offered the potential for privilege, health and wealth to its citizens.[25] Did it not have some horns that looked a bit lamb-like? It can’t be that bad, right? 

John did not write Revelation to manufacture a crisis for people complacent about empire. Rather, at that moment, complacency about Rome was the crisis. Why push them into the arenas their parents experienced when a temple feast will do?[26] 

See, by this time, Christians in Asia Minor were involved in the trade system of Rome. This is clear from historical records. That’s not a bad thing in and of itself, but participating in meals that included worship of the gods or the emperor was typically required to enter a Trade Guild or to build political connections. In order to have a comfortable life economically and socially, followers of Christ had to participate in the guilds and/or pagan ceremonies.[27]

Christians may have figured out how to gain just a part of the world, but it was costing them their soul.[28] This, I believe, is at the heart of what John will later describe as a mark that says “property of the Beast”[29]  – a sign of loyalty to the Empire and to Domitian.[30]  

* * * * * 

This was something that made sense to those churches, but it’s for us also. #whatisandwhatwillbe  So how are we like and unlike them? What can we learn from their experience? (I’m going to talk about losing and regaining our first love next week, so that’s not included here). 

• We will be known by our deeds. What deeds are we known for? Think big picture, patterns of behavior. “I know you, that you are ________. But I have this against you: _________”

• Do people think of us when they think of patient endurance in the midst of trials, or do they think of us as fainting/falling apart? When the going gets tough, who demonstrates patient endurance? When a pandemic storm hits, who models stability? When an election get volatile, who is unruffled? In a world where it’s easy to be blown about by the winds of false, slanderous, and disturbing information, who shows a dedication to accuracy and truth? In a time that feels like we are being forced into “us vs. them” camps more than ever, who builds righteous and godly bridges? Is this the reputation of the church right now?

• Do we protect the foundational teaching and practice of the faith? Do we unthinkingly buy the latest best-selling devotional or hop on the current Christian celebrity bandwagon, or are we purposeful Bereans, searching the Scriptures so that we recognize wheat and chaff when we see it?

• Do we justify mindsets and decisions because we are afraid of our Rome, seduced by our Babylon, or deceived by lamblike horns that front for the voice of the dragon? The United States is not exempt from John’s imagery in Revelation. It’s an empire. It is a Beastly Babylon. So is Canada, Mexico, Costa Rica, Switzerland, Afghanistan, Haiti, Norway… Are we alert, self-assessing, surrendering our lives to the scrutiny of the Holy Spirit and the Bible to see how we are identifying and rejecting the coercive power and alluring pleasure of the False Prophets that do the bidding of the Beast? It is inevitable that we will struggle. Are we caving in spiritually or morally because it’s just too hard to be a consistent follower of Jesus in this Rome? Because it’s just too costly? Are we crumbling spiritually or morally because the idol of pleasure, comfort, money, sex, power just look so good in this Babylon? What voices are shaping how we think about and live in the world? Practical example: should the US be taking refugees from Afghanistan? How much have you been listening to your favorite news host or politician to get direction? How much have you been diving into your Bible and listening to pastors and theologians and Christian organizations that work with refugees?

• Are our hearts and minds shaped by a focus on a joyful future or on current afflictions? Have you heard the proverb, “It is better to light a candle than curse the darkness?” There is a place to curse the darkness – especially if people don’t realize they are in it - but we can become so enamored with cursing the darkness that we forget to light a candle. We can hide the light of Christ under a bushel of anger, and fear, and resentment, and hostility. Surely those of us who have the hope of everlasting joy set before us can let the hope and joy found in Jesus illuminate the darkness around us. We can call the darkness what it is and show the light for what it is at the same time. But the best way to pull people from a spiritual darkness (that they might even love) is to flood it with the compelling glory of the light of Jesus.

• Could people ever look at our life and reasonably say the evidence points toward us having been ‘marked’ by a nation or a cultural leader instead of by Christ and the Kingdom of God?Whose image do we obviously bear when people look at us? We are marked by the image we most prominently display. Here, for example, are things that characterized Jesus. The more they characterize us, the more we are marked as belonging to God. #practicerighteousness

1.    Loving – loving people well   

2.    Peacemaker – bringing order to chaos

3.    Merciful – giving grace wherever possible

4.    Kind – treating others with goodness

5.    Faithful – someone others can count on

6.    Humble – having a modest/honest estimate of ourselves 

7.    Generous – giving appropriately to those in need

8.    Self-controlled – not ruled by our appetites

9.    Godly – constantly mindful of God’s perspective 

10.Prayerful – regularly communicating with God

11.Righteous – doing what God would approve

12.Servant – looking to serve rather than be served

13.Nurturing – caring for those who are hurting or broken 

Is this us? Is this you? Are we marked as followers of Jesus? 

7 “Let the person who is able to hear, listen to and follow [31] what the Spirit proclaims to all the churches. I will allow the one who conquers through faithfulness even unto death to eat from the tree of life found in God’s lush paradise.”[32]

Recommended Soundtrack:

“Zion and Babylon” by Josh Garrels

“Bye Bye Babylon” by White Heart.

_________________________________________________________________________

[1] Key resources that have heavily informed this series:

·      Apocalypse and Allegiance: Worship, Politics, and Devotion in the Book of Revelation,  by J. Nelson Kraybill

·      A teaching series by professor Shane J. Woods on Revelation (shanejwood.com)

·      The Bible Project’s videos, notes and podcast

·      Michael Heiser’s teaching on Revelation (Podcast: The Naked Bible)

·      Reading Revelation Responsibly: Uncivil Worship And Witness: Following The Lamb Into The New Creation, by Michael Gorman

·      Dragons, John, And Every Grain Of Sand, edited by Shane J. Wood.

·      Matt Chandler’s Revelation Series (Village Church)

·      Ancient Christian Commentary On Scripture: Revelation, from IVP

·      Seven Deadly Spirits: The Message of Revelation’s Letters for Today's Church, written by T. Scott Daniels

·      Adam Clarke’s commentary

·      Parts of Greg Beale’s commentary on Revelation

·      The commentaries available at Bible Gateway

·      The commentaries available at biblehub.com

·      The commentaries available at preceptaustin.com

[2] Apocalypse and Allegiance: worship, politics, and devotion in the Book of Revelation, J. Nelson Kraybill

[3] I recommend you watch or read A Monster Calls. Be ready to cry. It’s terribly beautiful.

[4] Beale suggests the “mystery” being revealed is that the reign of Christ and the suffering of the church can co-exist. Triumph is often intertwined with death. (Romans 11:25; 1 Corinthians 2:7; Ephesians 3:3-6)

[5] In Daniel 10 and 12, angels are show to help believers on earth.

[6] Hat tip to Beale for pointing this out.

[7]  Thanks to Seven Deadly Spirits: The Message of Revelation’s Letters for Today's Church, written by T. Scott Daniels, for intro material.

[8] Ephesus was known throughout the ancient world as the temple keeper (neōkoros; cf. Acts 19:35) of the goddess Artemis. 

[9] Acts 19:23-41

[10] “Jewish tradition recognized guardian angels of nations (based partly on Da 10:13,20 – 21) and of individuals; here the idea seems to be guardian angels of churches.” (NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible)  Beale argues this is to remind readers that their foundation is in heaven; their primary existence is spiritual. That makes sense to me.  However, Adam Clarke has a different perspective worth considering. “Unto the angel of the Church of Ephesus — By αγγελος, angel, we are to understand the messenger or person sent by God to preside over this Church; and to him the epistle is directed, not as pointing out his state, but the state of the Church under his care. Angel of the Church here answers exactly to that officer of the synagogue among the Jews called ציבור שליח sheliach tsibbur, the messenger of the Church, whose business it was to read, pray, and teach in the synagogue. The Church is first addressed, as being the place where John chiefly resided; and the city itself was the metropolis of that part of Asia. The angel or bishop at this time was most probably Timothy, who presided over that Church before St. John took up his residence there, and who is supposed to have continued in that office till A.D. 97, and to have been martyred a short time before St. John's return from Patmos.”  I like what Beale says; Clarke’s view makes a practical sense to me. It’s not a hill I’m going to die on J I’ll probably barely even put up a fight if we disagree.

[11] “The church had been founded by Paul about AD 53–56, and according to tradition, both John the Apostle and Mary (whom Christ committed to John's care at His crucifixion) lived in Ephesus.” (Orthodox Study Bible)

[12] Still making sure everyone knew Domitian’s son was not god….

[13] Churches. 7 of them. Weigh the numbers: it’s the weight of all the churches represented in these 7.

[14] “At Miletus Paul prophesied that even some of the Ephesian elders would tragically betray the cause of Christ by distorting the truth and leading away disciples (Acts 20:29–30). Timothy’s primary duty at Ephesus was to command certain persons to cease teaching false doctrine (1 Tim. 1:3). Hymenaeus, Alexander, and Philetus are even named as Ephesians who wandered from the truth (1:19–20; 2 Tim. 2:17–18).” (Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary Of The New Testament)

[15] “agápē – properly, love which centers in moral preference. So too in secular ancient Greek focuses on preference; likewise… antiquity meant "to prefer."  (HELPS Word Studies) “Jeremiah 2:2  “This is what the Lord says:‘I remember the devotion of your youth, how as a bride you loved me and followed me through the wilderness, through a land not sown.”

[16]  Love for Jesus (Eph 6:24) and/or one another (Eph 5:2).  

[17] “There is here an allusion to the candlestick in the tabernacle and temple, which could not be removed without suspending the whole Levitical service, so the threatening here intimates that, if they did not repent, c., he would unchurch them they should no longer have a pastor, no longer have the word and sacraments, and no longer have the presence of the Lord Jesus.” (Adam Clarke)

[18] Centers in moral choice, elevating one value over another. (HELPS Word Studies)

[19] (NIV Study Bible Notes)

[20] See Revelation 6:9-11

[21] Described as scarlet in Revelation 17

[22] “Come out of her, my people, so that you will not share in her sins…Your merchants were the world’s important people; by your magic spell all the nations were led astray.” (Revelation 18:4; 23)  Chapter 18 shows an international economic power with clients around the world, all engaging in the unbounded and often immoral pursuit of pleasure.

[23] Got a lot of the info in this list from the Wikipedia entry for Domitian. 

[24] Eusebius maintain that Jews and Christians were heavily persecuted toward the end of Domitian's reign when he Book of Revelation and First Epistle of Clement were written.

[25] Seven Deadly spirits: The message of Revelations letters for today's Church, written by T. Scott Daniels. John says that this goddess is instead the Great Horror who corrupted the Earth with her fornication in Revelation 19 2. She does not hold the cup of life, but rather a golden cup full of Abominations and the impurities of her fornication. Revelation 17:4.

[26] It’s the crisis the Russian church is facing right now. Putin pushes the traditional family model pretty hard, and he’s been pretty easy on the church. This is appealing to Russian Christians. In talking with my pastor friends in the Ukraine, the Russian church has become fond of Putin, a man who does the work of the Russian beast. This is the timeless relevance of Revelation.

[27] Paul does not reject all Christian participation in society. For example, he advocated a “don't ask” policy when believers have food set before them.[27] But this was very, very different from outright Christian participation in pagan rituals and ceremonies.

[28] Matthew 16:26

[29] As noted by Craig Koester, Revelation challenges three intertwined components of life in the Empire: political domination (“beastly side of empire); religion where the church and state distinctions blur (“deification of human power”); economic networks that demanded compromise (“the seamy side of commerce”)

[30] See Revelation 13

[31] Jesus uses this phrase (Matthew 13), borrowing this from Isaiah (6:9-10), Jeremiah (5:21), and Ezekiel (3:27)

[32] Genesis reference. Adam and Eve fellowshipped with God when they ate from the Tree of Life. That promise of fellowship is extended to the faithful who endure.